The definitive issue-by-issue comic book collecting guide and trade reading order for Marvel’s Punisher, Frank Castle comic books in omnibus, hardcover, and trade paperback collections. Part of Crushing Krisis’s Crushing Comics. Last updated April 2023 with titles scheduled for release through October 2023.
Collecting Punisher
Few characters chart the changing trends of the Marvel Universe as well as Frank Castle, The Punisher.
Punisher was initially introduced in 1974 as a vigilante foil to the rule-abiding Spider-Man. Punisher was a former marine who felt that any killer deserved death themselves, and that he would mete it out regardless of the progress of the justice system. Of course, Spider-Man did not remain in his sights for long, but Punisher was a quandary for the wallcrawler – was this man a hero he could team up with or a villain he had to stop?
The question was consistent with Marvel’s mid-70s output, which had begun to diversify its heroes and ask more challenging questions of them. However, that was the only space the Punisher could hold at the time – being a challenging question. There was no room for him as a star.
One of his prominent early-80s appearances was in Frank Miller’s Daredevil, who at the time was himself seen as a boundary-pushing vigilante. However, by contrast to the Punisher, his actions still seemed heroic. While he sometimes acted as a judge and even a jury, he never cast himself as an executioner.
By the mid-80s, violent heroes were on the rise at Marvel, and Punisher finally earned his own mini-series in 1986. That was quickly followed by one ongoing series, then two, then three – plus a regular flow of graphic novels and seasonal specials. By the height of his popularity and of comic speculation in 1992-93, Marvel releasing nearly as many pages of Punisher as they were Spider-Man. Yet, the later 90s were not kind to Frank Castle. The entire Marvel line had shifted towards the more extreme as well as massive game-changing gimmicks. Punisher’s edgy relaunch in 1995 (literally branded as part of the “Over the Edge” line) didn’t fare as well, and a pivot to having him be a supernatural avenger is one of the most reviled comic stories of the late 1990s. It seemed that Punisher had finally become irrelevant.
Frank Castle’s great savior was Marvel’s movement toward realism in the early 2000s, which was partially aligned with the leather-clad heroes in Fox’s first X-Men film. The Punisher drafted off this movement with “Welcome Back Frank,” which found Castle more grounded than ever in the hands of Preacher creators Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon. This gritty no-superheroes take on Punisher grew so popular that it spun off into it’s own out-of-continuity Punisher MAX series, which finally felt like the right format for the violent hero. He still had a role to serve in the main Marvel Universe, acting as a major instigator in the landmark Civil War, which mirrored Punisher’s own origin with heroes taking the law into their own hands.
Punisher now represents less of a shocking thread of violence and more the chance for Marvel to publish a comic in a different genre from its capes and spandex fare. Rick Remender found a way to make Frank Castle both more horrific and more lighthearted (if you can imagine), while Greg Rucka turned him into a on-the-streets mob book that could withstand an occasional intersection with Spider-Man. He even joined a team for the first time with the 2013 reinvention of Thunderbolts.
Punisher spawned a pair of films in 2004 and 2008, but he joined the Marvel Cinematic Universe in 2016 with Netflix’s Daredevil. With his exposure to the wider (and voracious) Marvel viewing public, he will likely remain a prominent feature in Marvel’s publishing line.
This guide is sponsored via Patreon by No Gods or Kings, an episodic novel by Thomas Judge.
First, this guide details standard collection series that covers most of Punisher’s early guest appearances and then half of his starring series. Then, I tackle Punisher’s titles issue-by-issue, chronologically from his debut through present day:
- Punisher Bookshelf – standard collected edition formats
- Reading Order
- Frank Castle, Before the Punisher
- The Anti-Hero (1974 – 1983)
- The 80s & 90s
- The 00s
- Marvel Now! (2012 – 2014)
- Thunderbolts (2012)
- All-New Marvel Now! (2014 – 2015)
- Original Sin (2014)
- The Punisher (2014) #1-20
- All-New, All-Different Marvel Now (2016)
- Daredevil/Punisher: Seventh Circle (2016) #1-4
- Doctor Strange/Punisher: Magic Bullets (2016)
- Deadpool vs. The Punisher (2017) #1-5
- Punisher: The Platoon (2017) #1-6
- The Punisher (2016) #1-17 & 218-228 by Becky Cloonan & Matthew Rosenberg
- The Punisher (2018) #1-16 by Matthew Rosenberg and Szymon Kudranski
- War of the Realms: Punisher (2019) #1-3 and Punisher Kill Krew (2019) #1-5 by Gerry Duggan
- Punisher (2022) #1-(ongoing) by Jason Aaron
& Punisher War Journal (2022) [various] by Torunn Grønbekk
- PunisherMAX – A self-contained, grounded continuity.
- Out-of-Continuity Series
Join the Crushing On Crushing Krisis mailing list for a notice whenever this page is updated with new collections – plus, a not-more-than-weekly ping about new comics content.
The Punisher Bookshelf
Epic Collections
Epic Collection Vol. 1: Not yet solicited, but will collect Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #129 & 134-135, Marvel Preview (1975) #2, Marvel Super Action (1975) #1, ASM #161-162 & 174-175, Captain America (1968) #241; ASM #201-202 & Annual (1964) 15, Daredevil (1964) #182-184; and Spectacular Spider-Man (1976) #81-83
Epic Collection Volume 2: Circle of Blood (2018 paperback, ISBN 978-1302914073 / 2023 paperback, ISBN 978-1302950477 / digital)
Collects Punisher (1986) #1-5, Punisher (1987) #1-10, Daredevil (1964) #257, and Marvel Graphic Novel: Punisher – Assassin’s Guild (which fits between #7-8)
Epic Collection Volume 3: Kingpin Rules (2019 paperback, ISBN 978-1302916411 / digital)
Punisher (1987) #11-25 & Annual 1-2
Epic Collection Volume 4: Return to Big Nothing (2021 paperback, ISBN 978-1302930851 / digital)
Collects Punisher (1987) #26-34 & Annual 3, Classic Punisher (1989) #1, Epic Graphic Novel: Punisher – Return to Big Nothing (1989), Marvel Graphic Novel: Punisher – Intruder (1989), and Punisher: Kingdom Gone (1990).
Epic Collection Volume 5: Jigsaw Puzzle (2020 paperback, ISBN 978-1302922757 / digital)
Collects Punisher (1987) #35-48 & Annual 4, Punisher: No Escape (1990) #1, Punisher: The Prize (1990) #1.
Epic Collection Volume 6: Not yet solicited, but should contain #49-62
Epic Collection Volume 7: Capital Punishment (2017 paperback, ISBN 978-1302907846 / digital)
Collects Punisher (1987) #63-75, Punisher: G-Force (1992), Punisher: Die Hard In The Big Easy (1992), Punisher/Black Widow: Spinning Doomsday’s Web (1992)
Volumes 8+: Not yet solicited, but should contain #76-102
Essentials
Marvel’s Essentials line packs tons of comics into each black and white, phone-book-sized edition with newsprint paper. If you don’t care about color and glossy paper, this is the best way to acquire your favorite classic stories quickly.
Essential Punisher, Vol. 1 (ISBN 078512375X)
Collects almost all of the “The Anti-Hero” era, below: The Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #129, 134-135, 161-162, 174-175, 201-202, & Annual 15, Captain America (1968) #241, Daredevil (1964) #182-184, Giant-Size Spider-Man (1974) #4, Marvel Preview (1975) #2, Marvel Super Action (1976) #1, The Spectacular Spider-Man (1976) #81-83, The Punisher (1986) #1-5. Originally printed in 2004 as ISBN 0785113649.
Essential Punisher, Vol. 2
Punisher #1-20 & Annual 1, plus Daredevil #257
Essential Punisher, Vol. 3
Punisher #21-40 & Annual 2-3
Essential Punisher, Vol. 4
Punisher #41-59 & Annual 4-5
The Essentials line has been discontinued and will not extend past #59. Jump to that spot in the chronology.
Punisher Reading Order
Frank Castle, Before The Punisher
Flashbacks to various points in Frank Castle’s history are scattered throughout his impressive run of comics, but there have been a few books that deal entirely with that pre-debut period of his story.
Punisher: The Platoon (2017) #1-6
This is a retcon story
Punisher Invades The ‘Nam
This collects the first three classic chronological Punisher stories, from The ‘Nam #67-69; Punisher Invades The ‘Nam: Final Invasion #1; and The ‘Nam #52-53, and adds to that additional material from Punisher War Journal (1988) #52-53 and Punisher War Zone (1992) #26-30.
The ‘Nam #67-69: In Invades, above.
Punisher Invades the ‘Nam: Final Invasion (1994) OGN (ISBN 0785100083)
In Invades, above. This story also includes modern-day components, and so is also covered below in the guide at its chronological placement.
The ‘Nam #52-53: In Invades, above.
Punisher: Year One #1-4
Billed as “Punisher War Journal, page one”
Punisher Bloodlines One-Shot
Punisher, The Anti-Hero (1974 – 1983)
Punisher made his debut as a villain attempting to assassinate Spider-Man! See Spider-Man for options for collecting all of the Spider-Man issues below (many of which are also collected in black and white in Essential Punisher, Vol. 1, above).
Punisher: Back To The War Omnibus
Mirrors the first Essential collection in amassing nearly all of Punisher’s earliest continuity appearances. Collects (in story order) Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #129 & 134-135, Marvel Preview (1975) #2, Marvel Super Action (1975) #1, ASM #161-162 & 174-175, Captain America (1968) #241; ASM #201-202 & Annual (1964) 15, Daredevil (1964) #182-184; Spectacular Spider-Man (1976) 81-83; and Punisher (1986) #1-5
That omnibus does skip a few minor and retroactively-inserted appearances – here’s the full list:
Amazing Spider-Man [ASM] #129 & 134-135
Punisher: The Origin of Microchip (1993) #1-2: Not collected. This origin story of one of Punisher’s major villains fits into Punisher’s early chronology.
Giant Size Spider-Man #4
Marvel Preview #2: This is the first solo Punisher story!
Marvel Super-Action #1
ASM #161-162 & 174-175
After #175: Code of Honor #2 (flashback)
Captain America #241: See Captain America
ASM #201-202 & Annual 15
Daredevil #181-184: See Daredevil
Peter Parker, The Spectacular Spider-Man #78-79 & 81-83
Punisher, Vol. 1 & Vol. 2, War Journal, and War Zone (1986 – 1995)
After appearing for years as a street-level vigilante in Spider-Man comic books (and taking a few-years break after 1983) Punisher finally broke through with this own limited series in 1986. it was planned for four issues, but extended to five – and quickly followed by an ongoing.
Punisher, Vol. 1 #1-5: Circle of Blood
Also available in hardcover and in Punisher: Back To The War Omnibus, above.
Punisher, Vol. 1 #1-5: Epic Collection Vol. 1: Circle of Blood
Collects Punisher (1986) #1-5, Punisher (1987) #1-10, Daredevil (1964) #257, and Marvel Graphic Novel: Punisher – Assassin’s Guild
Amazing Spider-Man #284-285 & 288: See Spider-Man
From this point forward, issues from “Punisher” will simply be listed as bolded issue numbers.
#1-10: Epic Collection Vol. 1: Circle of Blood
Issue #10 is a non-direct crossover to Daredevil #257. Collects Punisher (1986) #1-5, Punisher (1987) #1-10, Daredevil (1964) #257, and Marvel Graphic Novel: Punisher – Assassin’s Guild.
Punisher: Assassins Guild OGN (ISBN 0871354608)
Comes between #7-8. Also in Epic Collection Vol. 1 and in Punisher: Return To Big Nothing (2019 paperback, 9781302918965) in a collection of Return to Big Nothing, Assassin’s Guild, and Intruder.
After #7 and Assassins Guild: Strange Tales, Vol. 2 #12-14
Annual 1 & 11-13: Epic Collection Vol. 2: Kingpin Rules
Collects Punisher (1987) #11-25 & Annual 1-2. For Annual 1, also see Marvel Universe Events: Atlantis Attacks
After #13: Spectacular Spider-Man #140-143
Punisher War Journal, Vol. 1 begins here and is indicated with “PWJ.” Punisher issues continue to be listed as numbers only.
PWJ #1-3 & 8-9: Punisher: Shadowmasters (ISBN 9781302912024)
Collects Shadowmasters# 1-4; Punisher War Journal (1988) #1-3 & 8-9; and Punisher (1987) #24-25
PWJ #1-8: Punisher War Journal Classic, Vol. 1
PWJ #1-19: Punisher War Journal by Carl Potts & Jim Lee
Also includes material from Punisher Annual 2.
PWJ #6-7: Wolverine vs. Punisher (ISBN 978-1-302-90387-9)
Collects Punisher War Journal #6-7, Wolverine/Punisher: Damaging Evidence #1-3, Punisher War Zone #19, Wolverine/ Punisher: Revelation #1-4, Punisher (2001) #16-17, Wolverine (1988) #186, Wolverine/Punisher #1-5, Astonishing Tales: Wolverine/Punisher #1-6
#14-23, Annual 2, #24-25: Epic Collection Vol. 2: Kingpin Rules
Collects Punisher (1987) #11-25 & Annual 1-2. For Annual 2, also see Marvel Universe Events: Atlantis Attacks
Reading order:
PWJ #1-3, Punisher #14-18, PWJ #4-5
Punisher #19, Power Pack #46, PWJ #6-7
Punisher #20-23 & Annual 2, PWJ #8-9
#24-25: Punisher: Shadowmasters (ISBN 9781302912024)
Collects Shadowmasters# 1-4; Punisher War Journal (1988) #1-3 & 8-9; and Punisher (1987) #24-25
Annual 3 (1st & 2nd story) & #26-27: Not collected (except Essentials, above).
PWJ #9-11: Collected above with Potts & Lee. Issue #10 was Collected long ago in Marvel’s Greatest Super Battles (1994).
Punisher: Return to Big Nothing Epic Graphic Novel (ISBN 0871355531)
Reprinted in Punisher: Return To Big Nothing (2019 paperback, 9781302918965) in a collection of Return to Big Nothing, Assassin’s Guild, and Intruder.
Punisher: Intruder OGN (ISBN 0871355442)
Reprinted in Punisher: Return To Big Nothing (2019 paperback, 9781302918965) in a collection of Return to Big Nothing, Assassin’s Guild, and Intruder.
Reading Order:
PWJ #9, Punisher #24-25 & Annual 3, P: Return to Big Nothing, PWJ #10
Punisher #26-27, PWJ @11, Classic Punisher #1 (3rd story), P: Intruder
#28-29: Part of Acts of Vengeance. See Marvel Universe Events. This events includes a sequence of Punisher appearances from Moon Knight Vol. 3 #8-9, Punisher #28-29, PWJ #12-13, Damage Control Vol. 2 #2 & 4.
#30-34 & Annual 3 (3rd & 4th story): Not collected (except Essentials, above).
PWJ #12-19: Collected above with Potts & Lee and#12-13 with Acts of Vengeance, above.
PWJ #20-24 : Not collected
Punisher: No Escape OGN (ISBN 0871356465)
Stars US Agent and Paladin
Punisher: The Prize OGN (ISBN 0871357356)
Punisher: Kingdom Gone OGN (ISBN 087135652X)
Reading Order:
Moon Knight Vol. 3 #8-9, Punisher #28-29, PWJ #12-13, Damage Control Vol. 2 #2 & 4
Punisher #30-32, PWJ #14-15, Amazing Spider-Man #330-331, PWJ #16
Punisher #33-34 & Ann 3 (stories 3-4), Web of Spider-Man Annual 6 (2nd story), PWJ #17-24, ASM #337 (unconfirmed by official chronology), P:No Escape, P: The Prize, Impossible Man: Summer Vacation Spectacular #1 (5th story), Marvel Comics Presents #59, Ghost Rider Vol. 3 #5-6, P: Kingdom Gone
#35-48: Not collected (except Essentials, above).
PWJ #25-28: Not collected
Wolverine/Punisher: Damaging Evidence #1-3: Wolverine vs. Punisher (ISBN 978-1-302-90387-9)
Collects Punisher War Journal #6-7, Wolverine/Punisher: Damaging Evidence #1-3, Punisher War Zone #19, Wolverine/ Punisher: Revelation #1-4, Punisher (2001) #16-17, Wolverine (1988) #186, Wolverine/Punisher #1-5, Astonishing Tales: Wolverine/Punisher #1-6
Reading Order:
Punisher #35-40, Moon Knight Vol. 3 #19-21
Punisher #41-42, PWJ #25-27
Punisher #43, Uncanny X-Men #272, Fantastic Four #349
Punisher #44, New Warriors #7-9
Punisher #45-46, PWJ #28
Punisher #47-48, Wolverine/Punisher: Damaging Evidence #1-3, Damage Control Vol. 3 #4
Annual 4: Not collected (except Essentials, above). The primary story of Annual 4 is told entirely in flashback. Other stories fit here.
Punisher/Captain America: Blood and Glory #1-3: Captain America Epic Collection, Vol. 18: Blood and Glory (Epic Vol. 18)
Collects #398-410 and Punisher/Captain America: Blood and Glory (1992) #1-3
PWJ #29-37: Not collected
Punisher: P.O.V. #1-4: Not collected
Punisher Summer Special #1: Not collected
Ghost Rider / Wolverine / Punisher: Hearts of Darkness OGN (ISBN 0871358735)
This book was unusual in that it not only intertwined Punisher with other heroes, but also with a super-natural challenge. Reprinted in a 2017 TPB.
Punisher Bloodlines One-Shot
Punisher: Blood on the Moors OGN (ISBN 0871358549)
#49-62: Not collected.
Essentials collections end with #59
Reading Order:
Punisher Annual 4, Daredevil #292-293, Punisher/Captain America: Blood and Glory #1-3, Namor #16 & 18-20, PWJ #29-30
Punisher: P.O.V. #1-4, PWJ #31-34, ASM #353-358, Darkhawk #9, PWJ #35-36, Deathlok Vol. 2 #6-7, P: Summer Spectacular #1, PWJ #37
Ghost Rider / Wolverine / Punisher: Hearts of Darkness OGN, Marvel Comics Presents #101, P: Bloodlines, P: Blood on the Moors, PWJ #37 (again)
Punisher #49-52 (and then 64-70), P:The Ghosts of Innocents #1-2
Punisher #53-62
#63-75: Punisher Epic Collection: Capital Punishment (Epic Vol. 7)
Collects Punisher (1987) #63-75, Punisher: G-Force, Punisher: Die Hard In The Big Easy OGN, and Punisher/Black Widow: Spinning Doomsday’s Web OGN. This collection omits “The Ghosts of Innocents, which should be included here based on chronology. Issue #64 is also collected in Contest of Champions (2016) Vol. 2. Issue #63 falls in order below after Punisher War Zone #1-11 rather than with this sequence.
Punisher: The Ghosts of Innocents #1-2: Not collected
Punisher Holiday Special #1: Not collected
PWJ #38-41: Not collected
Punisher: G Force OGN (ISBN 0871358948)
Also collected in Capital Punishment, above.
Punisher War Zone starts here and is indicated with “PWZ.” Punisher issues continue to be listed as numbers only, Punisher War Journal as “PWJ.”
PWZ #1-6: Punisher War Zone, Vol. 1
#1 also collected in Marvel Visionaries: John Romita Jr. (2005)
PWZ #7-16: Not collected
#71-75 & Annual 5: Not collected. For annual See Marvel Universe Events: 1992 Annual Events,
PWJ #42-51: Not collected
Punisher Summer Special #2, Punisher: Back to School Special #1, & Punisher Holiday Special #2: Not collected
Punisher: Die Hard in the Big Easy OGN (ISBN 0871358751)
Also collected in Capital Punishment, above.
Punisher/Black Widow: Spinning Doomsday’s Web – Marvel Graphic Novel #74 (ISBN 0871357364)
Also collected in Capital Punishment, above.
Reading Order:
Punisher #64-70, P:The Ghosts of Innocents #1-2
Punisher #53-62, Cage #3-4, Punisher Holiday Special #1 (3rd story), Marvel Holiday Special 1991 (3rd story), PWJ #38-41, Punisher: G Force
PWZ #1-11, Punisher Summer Special #2, Moon Knight Vol. 3 #35-37
Punisher #63, Moon Knight Vol. 3 #38, PWJ #42-44, P: Die Hard in the Big Easy, Punisher/Black Widow: Spinning Doomsday’s Web, Motormouth #3-6 (#6 technically titled “Motormouth & Killpower”)
Punisher #71 & Annual 5, PWJ #45-46, Nomad Vol. 2 #5, Daredevil #308-309, Nomad Vol. 2 #6, PWJ #47
Punisher #72, Quasar #42, Hulk #395-396, Terror Inc #6-7, PWJ #48-49, 51, 50, Darkhold #4-5, Punisher: Back to School Special #1
Punisher #73-75, Punisher Holiday Special #1, Marvel Holiday Special 1992 (4th story), PWZ #12-16, Silver Sable and the Wild Pack #10, Spider-Man #32-34, Secret Defenders #4-5
#76-85 & Annual 6: Not collected except for #85 in Suicide Run, below.
PWJ #52-53: Punisher Invades The ‘Nam
This collects the first three classic and chronological Punisher stories, from The ‘Nam #67-69; Punisher Invades The ‘Nam: Final Invasion #1; and The ‘Nam #52-53, and adds to that Punisher War Journal (1988) #52-53 and Punisher War Zone (1992) #26-30.
PWJ #54-60: Not collected
Spider-Man / Punisher / Sabretooth: Designer Genes OGN (ISBN 0871359898)
Punisher Summer Special #3 & Punisher Back to School Special #2: Not collected
Venom: Funeral Pyre #1-3: Venom: The Enemy Within TPB
PWZ #17-22 & Annual 1: Not collected, except for #19 in Wolverine vs. Punisher
Punisher Invades the ‘Nam: Final Invasion OGN (ISBN 0785100083)
The modern-day elements of this story occur in this period
PWZ #26-30: The Punisher: Barbarian with a Gun
Also collected in Punisher Invades The ‘Nam
Reading Order:
Punisher #76-79, PWJ #52-56, Nightstalkers #5-6, Spider-Man / Punisher / Sabretooth: Designer Genes
Punisher #80, Punisher Summer Special #3, PWZ #17-19
Punisher #81, Venom: Funeral Pyre #1-3, PWZ Annual 1, PWJ #57-60
Punisher Annual 6, PunBSS 2
Punisher #82-84, Killpower: Early Years #2-3, PWZ #20-22, Super Soliders #8, Punisher Holiday Special #2, Thunderstrike #3
Okay, this takes some explaining.
Issue #85 is the beginning of the Suicide Run crossover story. However, there is a significant time gap between #85 and the next story chapter, which is in PWJ #61.
In that gap, Punisher Invades The ‘Nam: Final Invasion occurs – and is then followed by a handful of other stories as noted in the reading order above. Then, Punisher’s chronology continues in #89 (yes, after the Suicide Run crossover issues) and runs for a number of additional issues before finally the Suicide Run issues fit in.
Got it? Here we go.
Punisher #89-92: Not collected
Punisher Summer Special #4: Not collected
PWZ Annual 2: Not collected
Punisher Back to School Special #3: Not collected
Punisher #93: Not collected
PWZ #31-36: Punisher: River of Blood (ISBN 0785115420)
PWZ #37: Not collected; fits above, prior to Punisher #49
PWZ #38-40: Not collected.
Punisher Holiday Special #3
Ghost Rider / Wolverine / Punisher: The Dark Design OGN (ISBN 0752206915)
Reprinted in a 2017 TPB.
Punisher #86-102 & Annual 7. Not collected, except for #93 in The Best of Marvel 1994
#85-88 + PWJ #61-64 + PWZ #23-25: Punisher: Suicide Run
Collects the crossover between Punisher (1987) #85-88, Punisher War Journal (1987) #61-64, Punisher War Zone (1992) #23-25.
Suicide Run reading order #85, [gap], PWJ #61, PWZ #23, Punisher #86, PWZ #24, Punisher #87, PWJ #63, PWZ #25, Punisher #88. Epilogue in PWJ #64.
Punisher #94-102 & Annual 7: Not collected, except for #93 in The Best of Marvel 1994
PWJ #65-78: Not collected
Punisher: Empty Quarter OGN
Reading Order:
PWJ #65-69
Punisher #94-95, PWJ #71-73, P: Empty Quarter
Punisher Annual 7 & #96, PWJ #74
Punisher #97-100, PWJ #75
PUN #101-102, PWJ #78
Countdown: Not collected. The finale of Punisher’s three series, read as Punisher #103, PWJ #79, PWZ #41, Punisher #104, PWJ #80
After PWJ #79: Clandestine #7, Ghost Rider Vol. 3 #61, Blaze #10-12, Spider-Man: Power of Terror #2-4
Next in: Double Edge: Alpha, Spider-Man – Maximum Clonage Alpha, Web of Spider-Man #127, Daredevil #344, Ghost Rider Vol. 3 #65 (unconfirmed by official chronology), Hulk #433, Dr. Strange Vol. 3 #81 (implied behind-the-scenes), Double Edge: Omega
Punisher, Vol. 3 (1995 – 1997)
Punisher, Vol. 3 #1-4: Not collected
After #2: DC vs Marvel #1, and implied in 2-4 – though that series is not in continuity
Spider-Man/Punisher: Family Plot #1-2: See Spider-Man. This is collected in Spider-Man: The Complete Ben Reilly Epic, Vol. 02
Punisher, Vol. 3 #5-18: Not collected
After #6: Foxfire #3-4, Over the Edge #5, Doc Samson #3
During #16-17: Uncanny X-Men #341
After #18: Heroes for Hire #9, Spider-Man #89, Spectacular Spider-Man #255 Ka-Zar Vol. 4 #15-16, Spider-Man: Made Men
Punisher, Vol. 4 (1998) and Wolverine / Punisher (1998 – 1999)
Punisher briefly dies and then gains supernatural powers!
Punisher, Vol. #1-4: Marvel Knights Punisher by Golden, Sniegoski, & Wrightson: Purgatory
Also collects Wolverine / Punisher: Revelation #1-4
Wolverine / Punisher: Revelation #1-4: Wolverine vs. Punisher (ISBN 978-1-302-90387-9)
Avenging angel Punisher! Collects Punisher War Journal #6-7, Wolverine/Punisher: Damaging Evidence #1-3, Punisher War Zone #19, Wolverine/ Punisher: Revelation #1-4, Punisher (2001) #16-17, Wolverine (1988) #186, Wolverine/Punisher #1-5, Astonishing Tales: Wolverine/Punisher #1-6. Also in Purgatory, above.
Spider-Man vs. Punisher (2000): Marvel Knights Punisher by Peyer & Gutierrez: Taxi Wars
Billed as “an alternate retelling of Amazing Spider-Man #129. Collects Punisher (2001) #8-12, Punisher X-Mas Special (2006) #1, Spider-Man vs. Punisher #1, and material from Marvel Knights Double-Shot #4
Punisher, Vol. 5 (2000) & Vol. 6 (2001)
and Marvel Knights, Vol. 1 & Vol. 2 (2000-2004)
in oversize hardcover…
Punisher by Garth Ennis Omnibus oversize hardcover
Collects (2000) #1-12, Marvel Knights Double Shot #1, (2001) #1-7 & 13-37, and Punisher Kills the Marvel Universe. Reprinted in 2017.
as recollected in Complete Collections…
#1-5: Marvel Knights Punisher by Garth Ennis: The Complete Collection Vol. 1
Collects Punisher (2000) #1-12, Punisher (2001) #1-5, and Punisher Kills The Marvel Universe
#6-7 & 13-26: Marvel Knights Punisher by Garth Ennis: The Complete Collection Vol. 2
#8-12: Marvel Knights Punisher by Peyer & Gutierrez: Taxi Wars
Collects Punisher (2001) #8-12, Punisher X-Mas Special (2006) #1, Spider-Man vs. Punisher #1, and material from Marvel Knights Double-Shot #4
Marvel Knights Punisher by Garth Ennis: The Complete Collection Vol. 3
Collects Punisher (2001) #27-37 and Punisher War Zone (2008) #1-6
as originally collected (along with guest appearances)…
#1-12: Vol. 1: Welcome Back Frank
Collected variously: original 2001 paperback, 2003 hardcover, 2008 Marvel Premiere Classic, 2011 paperback
Appears in an out-of-continuity one-shot, Punisher/Painkiller Jane in 2001.
Deadpool, Vol. 3 #54-55
Marvel Knights (2000) #1-4: Marvel Knights by Dixon & Barreto: Defenders of the Streets
Collects Marvel Knights (2000) #1-15
Maximum Security #1: See Marvel Universe Events; between Marvel Knights #4-5
#1-7: Vol. 2: Army of One
After #6: Thunderbolts #57 (& 58 implied)
#8-12: Not collected
#13-18: Vol. 3: Business as Usual
Also available in hardcover. Issues #16-17 also in Wolverine vs. Punisher.
After #14: Marvel Knights Double-Shot #1
Marvel Knights, Vol. 2 #1-6: Not Collected. Falls between #15-16, followed by Marvel Knights Double-Shot #4 (2nd story)
#19: In Vol. 5, below
#20-26: Vol. 4: Full Auto
After #26: Wolverine #183
#27-32: Vol. 5: Streets of Laredo
Also includes #19
After #27: Wolverine #186, Agent X #2, Spider-Man: Get Kravel #1 (2nd story – in flashback)
#33-37: Vol. 6: Confederacy of Dunces
During #37: Daredevil Vol. 2 #65 (flashback), Captain Marvel Vol. 6 #2
Punisher, a series of mini-series (2004 – 2007)
As Punisher Max solidified itself as a take on an alternate-universe Punisher, his Marvel 616 narrative continued in a sequences of mini-series and one-shots that pick up directly from the end of his last story in #37.
Wolverine/Punisher #1-5
Recollected in Wolverine vs. Punisher
Punisher: Silent Night: Punisher: Very Special Holidays (2006) TPB
This was released after Daredevil vs. Punisher and before Punisher Vs. Bullseye. However, in chronology it’s placed here – Punisher was last in Wolverine/Punisher #5 and next in Punisher: Red X-Mas
Punisher: Red X-Mas: Punisher: Very Special Holidays (2006) TPB
After Red X-Mas: Spectacular Spider-Man #1000, Marvel Team-Up #8 & 10, Marvel Knights Spider-Man #15
Daredevil vs. Punisher: Means and Ends
Collects the six-issue limited series. Reprinted in 2016.
After DvP: Underworld #3-4, Dr. Strange (06) #2
After PvB: Daughters of the Dragon #4-5
Punisher: Bloody Valentine: Punisher: Very Special Holidays (2006) TPB
After BV: DD2 84-85, ASM 533, DD2 86-87, Moon Knight, Vol. 6 #9-10, Civil War #4
Punisher: X-Mas Special #1 (2007): Marvel Knights Punisher by Peyer & Gutierrez: Taxi Wars
I’m not 100% sure about this, but it’s January 2007 cover date and Marvel is referring to the issue in this collection as 2006 – which is when it would’ve physically hit the shelves.
Punisher War Journal, Vol. 2 (2007 – 2009)
in a 2019 series of Complete Collections…
#1-12: by Matt Fraction: The Complete Collection Vol. 1
as originally collected…
#1-4: Vol. 1: Civil War
Paperback reprinted in 2016.
Civil War: See Marvel Universe Events. Punisher also makes a brief but impactful appearance in the main Civil War mini-series.
After #1: Civil War #5
During #2: Civil War #6, Amazing Spider-Man #537
#5-11: Vol. 2: Goin’ Out West
Available in hardcover
#12-17: Vol. 3: Hunter Hunted
Available in hardcover
After #15: Marvels Channel: Marvels, Myths & Monsters #1 (digital), Eternals Vol. 4 #1
Annual 1: Collected below with Vol. 5
After #17: ASM 577, RUN2 25-26 & 30
#18-23: Vol. 4: Jigsaw
Available in hardcover.
#24-26 & Annual: Vol. 5: Secret Invasion
Annual fits before #16, above. Available in hardcover
After #25: Wolverine Vol. 3 #73
Astonishing Tales: Wolverine/Punisher #1-6: Wolverine vs. Punisher (ISBN 978-1-302-90387-9)
Digital Comic collected as Astonishing Tales #1 in 2009. Collects Punisher War Journal #6-7, Wolverine/Punisher: Damaging Evidence #1-3, Punisher War Zone #19, Wolverine/ Punisher: Revelation #1-4, Punisher (2001) #16-17, Wolverine (1988) #186, Wolverine/Punisher #1-5, Astonishing Tales: Wolverine/Punisher #1-6
After AT: Ghost Rider Vol. 6 #32
Punisher War Zone, Vol. 2 (2009) #1-6: Punisher: The Resurrection of Ma Gnucci
Also available in hardcover and in Marvel Premiere Hardcover trade dress. Reprinted as Marvel Knights Punisher by Garth Ennis: The Complete Collection Vol. 3 along with Collects Punisher (2001) #27-37
Punisher by Rick Remender (2009 – 2011)
This run is collected in it’s entirety in a single omnibus
Punisher by Rick Remender Omnibus Oversize Hardcover
Collects Punisher Vol. 9 (2009) #1-16 & Annual 1; Dark Reign: The List – Punisher #1; Franken-Castle #17-21; Dark Wolverine #88-89; Punisher: In The Blood 1-5
It was also collected in a series of original release hardcovers and paperbacks, starting with Punisher Vol. 9.
#1-6: Vol. 1: Dark Reign
Available in hardcover.
After #2: Deadpool: Suicide Kings #1-5, Moon Knight #26-30
#6-10 & Annual 1: Vol. 2: Dead End
Annual 1 falls directly after #6. Available in hardcover.
Amazing Spider-Man Presents: Anti-Venom #1-3
Comes directly after #10. Punisher appears throughout.
After #10 & Anti-Venom: Hulk #14-15, Fall of the Hulks: Red Hulk #2 (FB), Hulk #16-17, Doctor Voodoo: Avenger of the Supernatural #4, Girl Comics #1 (3rd story), then Dark Reign: The List – Punisher, collected directly below.
#11-21: Punisher: FrankenCastle
Collects Dark Reign: The List – Punisher, Punisher #11-16, Franken-Castle #17-21, Dark Wolverine #88-89. Dark Reign: The List – Punisher occurs during #11. The crossover sequence is FC 18, DW 88, FC 19, DW 89. Also available in oversized hardcover, though that was superseded by the Omnibus, above.
After #16: Deadpool Team-Up #894
Punisher: In the Blood #1-5
This five-issue mini-series wraps up Remender’s run on the title.
After In the Blood: Incredible Hulk #615 (2nd story)
Chaos War: See Marvel Universe Events. Punisher appears in #4
Shadowland: See Marvel Universe Events. Punisher makes brief but pivotal appearances in Shadowland: Spider-Man #1, Shadowland #4-5, and Heroes for Hire #4-5
Punisher, Vol. 10 & Punisher: War Zone by Greg Rucka (2011 – 2012)
Greg Rucka takes over the title for a back-to-basics New York City story, although over the course of the run it blossoms into super-powered conflict with the Avengers.
Before #1 :Captain America Corps (2011) #4-5
#1-5: Vol. 1
Also includes material from Spider-Island: I Love New York City, which fell after #4
After #4: Dark Avengers (2012) #179,Deadpool (2008) #49.1, Spider-Island: Emergence of Evil – Jackal & Hobgoblin, Spider-Island: I Love New York City, Uncanny X-Force (2010) #28-29
#6-10: Vol. 2
Includes a crossover with Daredevil #11 and Avenging Spider-Man #6
After #10 & Daredevil #11: Incredible Hulk (2011) #8
#11-16: Vol. 3
Punisher: War Zone #1-5
A five -issue mini-series closing out Rucka’s run on the title.
After PWZ #5: Avenging Spider-Man #11 (placement unconfirmed), The Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #695
Punisher: Nightmare
A five-issue mini-series that occurs after Rucka’s run on the ongoing. Exact placement (or continuity) is unclear.
Punisher in Marvel Now! (2012 – 2014)
Punisher appears in every issue of Thunderbolts (2013), sometimes acting as the central character and driving force of the series. It also includes some unfortunate character development in combination with Elektra and Deadpool.
Thunderbolts #1-9: See Thunderbolts.
Thunderbolts #10-13: See Thunderbolts
After #13: Avenging Spider-Man (2012) #22
The Trial Of The Punisher (2013) #1-2: Punisher & Bullseye: Deadliest Hits (ISBN 978-1-302-90578-1)
Finally, this series sees collection! Also collects Bullseye: Perfect Game #1-2 and material from Daredevil #500
Thunderbolts #14-26 & Annual 1: See Thunderbolts
After Thunderbolts #26: The Superior Foes of Spider-Man (2013) #2-3 & 16-17, Superior Spider-Man Team-Up (2013) #9-10, Nova (2013) #10, Daredevil (2011) #36, Deadpool: Dracula’s Gauntlet (digital issues #11-13; print issues #6-7), Deadpool (2013) #27
Thunderbolts #27-32: See Thunderbolts
Daredevil End of Days #5-8: See Daredevil. This story is not in continuity.
Punisher in All-New Marvel Now! (2014 – 2015)
Original Sin: See Marvel Universe Events. Uncharacteristically for Punisher, he is a primary character in this Marvel Universe event, appearing in all eight issues plus between #6-7 in Original Sins (2014) #5. This story does not fundamentally alter his arc headed into his next series, but it’s a good one.
#1-6: Vol. 1: Black and White
#7-12: Vol. 2: Border Crossing
Includes Black Widow #9, which fits between #9-10.
#13-20: Vol. 3: Last Days
After #17: Black Widow (2014) #12, Wolverines (2015) #3 & 13
Secret Wars: See Marvel Universe Events. Punisher makes a single-panel appearance in this event (it’s a fun panel)
All-New, All-Different Marvel (2016 – 2017)
Frank Castle didn’t immediately bounce back from Secret Wars into his own book. Instead, he had a string of mini-series in All-New, All-Different Marvel that continued through his next ongoing title.
Daredevil/Punisher: Seventh Circle (2016) #1-4
Doctor Strange/Punisher: Magic Bullets (2016)
Collects an internet-first Infinite Comics series
Deadpool vs. The Punisher (2017) #1-5
Punisher: The Platoon (2017) #1-6
This is a retcon story that fits into Punisher’s earliest years.
The Punisher (2016) #1-17 & 218-228
Frank Castle returns in a series written by Becky Cloonan with Punisher’s long-time artist, Steve Dillon. Dillon tragically passed away during his work on the series. Cloonan tells a single story in her first 12 issues, and then a series of one-shot stories in her final run.
Then, in Marvel Legacy, writer Matthew Rosenberg takes over for a run where Frank Castle dons the War Machine armor!
#1-6: Vol. 1: On The Road
#7-12: Vol. 2: End of the Line
#13-17: Vol. 3: King of the New York Streets
#218-223: War Machine, Vol. 1
I confirmed this to include #223 in the book’s indicia despite the solicit saying otherwise.
#224-228: War Machine, Vol. 2
The Punisher (2018) #1-16 by Matthew Rosenberg and Szymon Kudranski
Matthew Rosenberg continues the themes of his Marvel Legacy into a new series that finds Frank Castle out of the War Machine armor but still waging a one-man war against Baron Zemo and Bagalia.
#1-5: Vol. 1: World War Frank (2019 paperback, ISBN 978-1302913472 / digital)
#6-11: Vol. 2: War in Bagalia (2019 paperback, ISBN 978-1302913489 / digital)
#12-16: Vol. 3: Street by Street, Block by Block (2019 paperback, ISBN 978-1302919023 / digital)
War of the Realms: Punisher (2019) #1-3 and Punisher Kill Krew (2019) #1-5 by Gerry Duggan
Gerry Duggan tells the story of vengeance in the midst of War of the Realms and follows it up with a mini-series of Frank Castle cleaning up loose ends from the event.
War of the Realms: The Punisher (2019 paperback, ISBN 978-1302919054 / digital)
Collects #1-3 and material from War of the Realms: War Scrolls (2019) #3 and material War of the Realms: Omega (2019) #1 [both confirmed in the indicia of the actual book]. See Guide to Marvel Universe Events – War of the Realms for more collecting options.
Punisher Kill Krew (2020 paperback, ISBN 978-1302919030 / digital)
Collects #1-5 (and maybe also material War of the Realms: Omega (2019) #1)
Punisher (2022) #1-(ongoing) by Jason Aaron
& Punisher War Journal (2022) [various] by Torunn Grønbekk
Jason Aaron writes an in-continuity Frank Castle series for the first time. This book combines grounded elements of Frank’s childhood, time in the war, and return to civillian life with supernatural aspects, courtesy of The Hand.
#1-6: The King of Killers, Book 1 (2022 paperback, ISBN 978-1302928773 / digital)
Punisher War Journal (2023 paperback, ISBN 978-1302932855 / digital)
Collects all three one-shots that accompany this main Jason Aaron run – Punisher War Journal: Base (2023) #1, Punisher War Journal: Blitz (2022) #1, and Punisher War Journal: Brother (2022) #1
#7-12: The King of Killers, Book 2 (2023 paperback, ISBN 978-1302928780 / digital TBA)
Punisher MAX
Launched by the same team behind his 2000 back-to-basics Marvel Knights series, this MAX series quickly proved itself to be in its own self-contained continuity – sans any other superheroes or supervillains.
Click to expand a list of Punisher MAX collections.
Punisher: The Tyger (2006) #1: Punisher in Out-of-Continuity Series
Punisher: A Man Named Frank OGN (ISBN 0785100555)
Punisher vs. the Marvel Universe
Collecting: Punisher Kills The Marvel Universe, Amazing Spider-Man (1963) #161-162, Heroes For Hire (1997) #9, Punisher (2001) #33-37, Punisher War Zone (2012) #1-5, Marvel Universe Vs. Punisher #1-4
Didn’t find what you were looking for?
Check Amazon for Marvel’s newest Punisher titles.
Back to Back to Crushing Comics
Punisher’s appearance in Spectacular Spider-man is misplaced as this story is a reprint of the comic Amazing Spider-Man #129.
Also missing the out of continuity Punisher Noir
Punisher a man named Frank is technically in continuity as well, it happens on Earth-616 just set back in the 19th century or so and happens to feature another guy named Frank who became a punisher type figure
Punisher The Platoon is a MAX continuity series and should be listed with the rest of them