• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Crushing Krisis

The Newest Oldest Blog In New Zealand

  • DC Guides
    • DC Events
    • DC New 52
    • DC Rebirth
    • Batman Guide
    • The Sandman Universe
  • Marvel Guides
    • Marvel Events
    • Captain America Guide
    • Iron Man Guide
    • Spider-Man Guide (1963-2018)
    • Spider-Man Guide (2018-Present)
    • Thor Guide
    • X-Men Reading Order
  • Indie & Licensed Comics
    • Spawn
    • Star Wars Guide
      • Expanded Universe Comics (2015 – present)
      • Legends Comics (1977 – 2014)
    • Valiant Guides
  • Drag
    • Canada’s Drag Race
    • Drag Race Belgique
    • Drag Race Down Under
    • Drag Race Sverige (Sweden)
    • Drag Race France
    • Drag Race Philippines
    • Dragula
    • RuPaul’s Drag Race
    • RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars
  • Archive
  • Contact!
You are here: Home / consume / comic books / Review: Butterfly by Amel, Bennett, Fuso, & Simeone

Review: Butterfly by Amel, Bennett, Fuso, & Simeone

June 2, 2016 by krisis

I’ve always loved the risk/reward of a blind buy.

I’m not talking about buying a new appliance sight unseen here. I’m talking about more subjectively judged products, like music you’ve never heard or heard of or a dish of unfamiliar food of which the only detail you are only certain it is not poison.

If we always seek out what we know and have been recommended, how can we ever be surprised? Some of my favorite albums came from picking something up purely because of a band’s name or their photo, and the vast majority of my indie comic collection came from trying something without knowing a thing about it other than the aesthetics of a cover image or a few lines of promotional copy.

(How sure can you be about art until you consume it, anyway? Did that dance about architecture really tell you how great the building would be?)

That’s nearly all I had to go by on Butterfly. I had read scripter Marguerite Bennett as a co-author with a major favorite, Kieron Gillen, but that didn’t speak much for her on her own. The cover image is stark – the shape of an olive butterfly on a black background formed by the silhouettes of dozens of guns.

Butterfly_HC_coverThere was something about it that made me want to own it.

Butterfly 2.5 stars Amazon Logo

Collects Butterfly #1-4. Story by Arash Amel, script by Marguerite Bennett, illustrated by Antonio Fuso and Stefano Simeone with colors by Adam Guzowski, lettering by Steve Wands.

#140char review: Butterfly: an icy spy tale that doesn’t bother to wash the blood from its hands. A less touchy Alias or a less fanciful Mind MGMT. Just okay

CK Says: Consider it.

Butterfly is not at all as delicate as its namesake. That goes for both the book on the whole and the main character, for whom its an alias.

We’re dropped into a mission already in progress with Rebecca Faulkner AKA Butterfly, and from the get she seems like more of a chameleon than a butterfly. She seamlessly slides into character for a dead drop and is just as facile in her initial exfiltration. However, when she discovers her routine contacts have all been disconnected she is forced to rely on a failsafe that puts her on a path to intersect her retired spy of a father, long since disappeared from her life.

Something I’ve begun to appreciate both Marguerite Bennett both here and in other work is not only the efficiency of her language but the efficient placement of her writing. She is unafraid to let the artwork tell the story before remarking on it, even though here the art does not always have enough motion to fulfill the promise.

Antonio Fuso’s work has a lot of hard edges, and the occasionally blocky characters don’t always portray movement enough to make up for Bennett’s silences. The latter portion by Stefano Simeone is more fluid and engaging, with sketched edges left rough to imbue his characters with vibration and life. Adam Guzowski’s colors are noticeably strong throughout – I felt he used a lot of subtle changes in hue and saturation to soften Fuso’s pencils, whereas he felt extremely organic over Simeone’s looser art. (Covers by the extraordinary Phil Noto will leave you longing for his work on the interiors.)

Butterfly_HC_PRESS-12The net result is a number of jarring scenes with small, brutal details presented with an utter lack of apology.  And, while I didn’t always enjoy the aesthetic presentation, it’s that brutality that makes this book so compelling. Rebecca wants to second-guess her father’s long term actions, yet her own choices range from obviously bad to terrifyingly ambiguous, leaving the consequences to our imaginations. Despite the constant tease of familiar reconciliation, there’s no hard edges gone soft like in the frequently tearful JJ Abrams’ Alias, or soft spots becoming blind spots like in Matt Kindt’s fanciful but cutthroat Mind MGMT.

Yet, like Mind MGMT, this is a fractured narrative whose proper structure you must intuit because it is never spoken. David’s story moves backwards in time from his intersection with Rebecca, but it does so clumsily – not in digestible scenes, but single pages simply reversed in chronology despite the forward motion of David’s narration. While it’s appropriate jarring and mysterious, as we circle the origin point of David’s story it seems less and less important – the pea under a mattress amplified over the distance of time.

The wider brutality of this book is the distance between us and the characters. We never meet a version of Rebecca we can care about – only a spy on the run. I’m all for skipping the foreplay of a script and starting with the action, but the result is that she comes off as flat as we’re expected to engage emotionally with her father instead.

Butterfly was satisfying to finish reading, because at the end of its carefully fractured narrative so many details click into place. However, it fails my litmus test for cleverly structured narratives – it’s dull on re-read. Having the details up front breaks any fascinating spell the book held over me.

That means the beauty of this book is in the eye of the beholder. Will you be satisfied by a slightly challenging narrative that’s part visceral spy-vs-spy and part geo-political intrigue if it’s actually quite plain upon review? If you’re seeking a more enduring riddle, this isn’t your book.

Even as I struggled to stay engaged with David’s side of the story, I ended my read in appreciation. Amel and Bennett have accomplished a delicate slight of hand, tricking us into looking for a larvae exploding into something beautiful when instead we’re meant to be carefully sensing the subtle flap of wings that creates a hurricane of senseless violence later.

(It did not escape my notice that Archaia’s matte-finish hardcover is well-constructed and pleasant to hold. Archaia’s an imprint of Boom Studios, but where Boom’s trade paperbacks can fell blocky and inflexible, Archaia’s graphic novels are objects of note and hefty.)

Related posts:

  1. Review: Birthright, Vol. 1 – Homecoming, by Williamson & Bressan
  2. X-Men Reading Order Guide – Era #12: Endangered Species
  3. X-Men Reading Order Guide – Era #4: X-Factor
  4. X-Men Reading Order Guide – Era #6: Fatal Attractions
  5. X-Men Reading Order Guide – Era #11: The New Age

Filed Under: comic books, reviews Tagged With: Adam Guzowski, Antonio Fuso, Arash Amel, Archaia, Butterfly, indie comics, Marguerite Bennett, Stefano Simeone

Previous Post: « Review: Wolf, Vol. 1 – Blood and magic, by Kot, Taylor, Loughridge, Cowles, & Muller
Next Post: zoological perspectives »

Primary Sidebar


Support Crushing Krisis on Patreon
Support CK
on Patreon


Follow me on Twitter Contact me Watch me on Youtube Subscribe to the CK RSS Feed

About CK

About Crushing Krisis
About My Music
About Your Author
Blog Archive
Comics Blogs Only
Contact Krisis
Terms & Conditions

Crushing Comics

Marvel Comics

Marvel Events Guide

Spider-Man Guide

DC Comics

  • Guide to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IDW ContinuityNew for Patrons: Guide to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IDW Continuity
    Dig into over 200 issues of turtle power in perfect story order with my Guide to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles comics at IDW! […]
  • Drag Race Sverige Season 1, Episode 3 – “Drag-a’-mera!” design challenge Review & Power Ranking
    The queens of Drag Race Sverige stress over a Drag-a'-mera unconventional materials design challenge and a pair of intimidating judges in Christer Lindarw & Fredrik Robertsson. […]
  • New for Patrons: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – Guide to Mirage Studios Continuity
    Curious about the b&w indie comic origins of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles? my Guide to Mirage Studios Continuity covers every issue! […]
  • Drag Race Belgique Season 1, Episode 5 – Snatch Game & Night of 1001 Audrey Hepburns Runway
    The queens of Belgique compete in a oddly low-key Snatch Game and a Night of 1001 Audrey Hepburns runway that emphasized realness over glam. […]
  • RuPauls Drag Race Season 15 Episode 12 - Wigloose The Rusical Title CardRuPaul’s Drag Race Season 15, Episode 12 – “Wigloose The Rusical” Review & Power Ranking
    Wigloose is one of the best Rusicals ever, and it arrives at the perfect moment to address anti-drag, anti-LGBTQA* legislation across America. […]
  • Updated: Guide to X-Men Legacy
    I updated my Guide to X-Men Legacy, but it's more like an anti-update - since Marvel has yet to get around to recollecting Mike Carey's incredibly run. […]
  • Guide to GamoraNew for Patrons: Guide to Gamora
    Learn more about Thanos's adopted daughter and the most dangerous woman in the galaxy in this Guide to Gamora, of the Guardians of the Galaxy […]
  • New for Patrons: Guide to Shadowhawk by Jim Valentino
    If you've spent some portion of the past 30 years curious about Jim Valentino's Image Comics hero, my new Guide to ShadowHawk explains his history and how to find every issue in reading order. […]
  • Drag Race Sverige Season 1, Episode 2 – “MARATHON Talent Hunt” Review & Power Ranking
    It's the "MARATHON Talent Hunt" as Drag Race Sverige puts on a talent show with some shocking acts, followed by a Pippi Longstocking runway. […]
  • Shazam Guide, The Captain Marvel of DC Comics – now available to the public!
    Excited for Shazam! Fury of the Gods but unsure where to start reading his comics? My Shazam Guide covers EVERY appearance from 1940 to today! […]
  • Drag Race Belgique Season 1, Episode 4 – “L’émission qui vous déshabille” acting challenge & “Ceci n’est pas un look!” runway Review & Power Ranking
    Drag Race Belgique delivered a brainy episode filled with culture with a spoof of the documentary "Ni Juge, Ni Soumise" and a Magritte-inspired "Ceci N’est Pas un Look" surrealist runway. […]
  • RuPaul's Drag Race Season 15 Episode 11 - Two Queens One Joke - Comedy Luxx Noir London Loosey LaDucaRuPaul’s Drag Race Season 15, Episode 11 – “Two Queens, One Joke” Review & Power Ranking
    The Top 7 queens of RuPaul's Drag Race Season 15 take the stage for a Two Queens One Joke comedy challenge and a Rip Her To Shreds runway. […]
  • Updated: Guide to New X-Men by Grant Morrison
    My Guide to New X-Men is freshly updated with the newest reprinting of the New X-Men by Grant Morrison omnibus, the final Peter Milligan recollection, and more. […]
  • New for Patrons: Guide to Brigade
    I think you've forgotten one of Image's earliest comics. It's about a disgraced super soldier leading a vigilante team dedicated to justice. Ring any bells? […]

Layout copyright © 2017 · Foodie Pro Theme by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress

Links from Crushing Krisis to retailer websites may be in the form of affiliate links. If you purchase through an affiliate link I will receive a minor credit as your referrer. My credit does not affect your purchase price. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to: Amazon Services LLC Associates Program (in the US, UK, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, and Spain), eBay Partner Network, and iTunes Affiliate Program.