I’m here with my weekly peek at Marvel’s collected editions, packing recent and classic comic storylines into handy hardcovers and trade paperbacks.
Since I’m still at a bit of a lag, this week we’re taking a lot at all of October – and there were a slew of great collections that month! Read on for capsule reviews of the X-Men books out in October, plus the skinny on all of Marvel’s other new collected editions from last month.
If you’re looking for more X-Men books, head over to my Definitive Guide to Collecting X-Men Graphic Novels. Or, some X-background, read my Intro to X-Men (on a budget). Trying to decide where to jump in? Check out Where to Start Reading X-Men.
Marvel X-Men Collection of the Month:
Daken: Dark Wolverine – Big Break Hardcover
Collects issues #10-14 and 9.1
CK Says: Buy it! This isn’t the first time I’ve featured Daken as my top pick, and it won’t be the last. There’s something about the dastardly, amoral, bisexual, pheromone-exuding, tattooed, illegitimate son of Wolverine that I find delightfully subversive when written well, and a year into his solo outing Rob Williams has him down pat.
This collection finds Daken trying to take control of LA the only way he knows how – putting the screws to the existing bad-guys a la Joker in Dark Knight, and sleeping his way into secrets of the scene with a young up-and-coming actor.
The twist? Daken samples the street drug du jour and is both terrified and thrilled to find it shuts off his healing factor! The result are some bloodier-than-usual fights as Daken enjoys handicapping himself while tripping out in Ralph Steadman-esque illustrations. (PS: The interiors are not quite so froggy as the front cover.) Available for pre-order as a TPB.
Marvel Non-X Collection of the Month:
Fantastic Four by Jonathan Hickman Vol. 4 TPB
Collects Fantastic Four #583-588
CK Says: Buy it. Writer Jonathan Hickman has re-made a Fantastic Four fan out of me with his operatic two-year run leading up to the issues in this collection. He divides comics’ first family with a war on multiple fronts against traditional foes like Galactus, Namor, and Annihilus as well as by their hard feelings at home, but this story is anything but old school.
Though the big build-up was for the death of a team-member, what’s really worth witnessing here is the rebirth of the FF franchise as one of Marvel’s hottest titles. Interior artist Steve Epting draws such stately, beautiful characters you’ll swear you’re reading Superman.
You may want to pick up Volumes 1, 2, and 3 as well – you can score the entire four-volume run for under $50! Also available in hardcover.
What X-title do I hate with such a passion that I have to abstain from giving it a rating at all? Keep reading to find out, plus get capsule reviews of books from X-Men: Legacy, X-Factor, and X-23 and summaries of the rest of the Marvel Universe.
Iron Age Hardcover
Collects Iron Age #1-3, Alpha, and Omega
CK Says: Consider it! Yes, this is an Iron Man title in the midst of the X-Collections. Why? Check out this insanity: Tony Stark gets sucked back in time to when he was a consummate drunkard, so none of the past Avengers will believe his alcoholic self when he says the Earth is at risk from Dark Phoenix (!!!), so he recruits pretty much my two favorite B-list X-Men to assist him: Captain Britain and Dazzler! I swear, that’s not even an exaggeration in the least. This will surely be a Christmas gift to myself.
New X-Men Vol. 6: Assault on Weapon Plus Digest
Collects New X-Men #139-145
CK Says: Consider it. While not my favorite of Morrison’s X-Men stories, I’m actually fond of Cyclops and Wolverine team-ups. Add the acerbic wit and constant subterfuge of the still-new Fantomax and the accelerated time environment of The World and you have a tidy little action tale. Also available in New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Vol 3.
Wolverine: Wolverine’s Revenge Hardcover
Collects Wolverine #10-14
CK Says: $*#! It turns out I am part of a rare 1% of comic fans who despise pretty much every concept and script from one of comics’ hottest authors, Jason Aaron. This collection, in particular, bothered me to the core by setting up an predictable and utterly cliched climax and then paying off every maudlin ounce of it. Yet, all the fans rejoiced heartily, proclaiming it the best Wolverine story in years, and the art was rather awesome, so what do I know? Available for pre-order as a TPB.
X-23, Vol. 1: The Killing Dream TPB
Collects issues #1-6, and a brief story from Wolverine Saga
CK Says: Skip it. Wolverine’s teenage girl clone headlines an increasingly fan-favorite series (canceled as of today!), but it had a slow start. That was made all the more obvious by comparison to her spectacular past headlining gigs, as on her introductory mini-series and the stellar (and back-to-print!) Target X. Here we pick up Gambit as a supporting character, a simpering Ms. Sinister as a villain, and strong art from Will Conrad, but it will take until the next collection for writer Marjorie Liu to strike the right tone on this title. Also available in hardcover.
X-Factor: Hard Labor Hardcover
Collects X-Factor #219-224
CK Says: Consider it. I just re-read this story last week, and it is a bit of an empty-calorie meal. While there are some amusing bits (Shatterstar’s discovery of musicals is hilarious), on the whole it largely depends on your connection to former New Mutant wolfgirl Rahne, who is pregnant with the spawn of a wolf god. With the rest of the cast mostly on the sidelines, this continues X-Factor’s slower burn after some phenomenal stories heading into the 210s. Available for pre-order as a TPB.
X-Men Legacy: Lost Legions
Collects X-Men Legacy #250-253
CK Says: Consider it (presently 40% off at Amazon!). This slow, almost somber mission to recapture escaped multiple identities of Xavier’s son Legion features one of the oddest X-teams ever: Magneto and Xavier, Rogue and Gambit, Legion, and former-villain strong-woman Frenzy.
We don’t get to see Erik or Charles do anything especially excellent, but Rogue is the star of the show and Frenzy’s every line is sheer nasty – even when she’s saving the day. Rogue fans would be better off with earlier storylines Emplate or Collision, but longterm Legacy readers will appreciate her continued development here as author Mike Carey stretches the bounds of what her powers can do now that she is in full control of them. Available to pre-order as a TPB.
Wow – October had a lot of X! And now, for the rest of Marvel’s offerings this month…
Anita Blake, Vampire Hunter: Guilty Pleasures Ultimate Collection TPB – Collects a 12-issue series of the same name. Available in hardcover as “The Complete Edition.”
Captain America: Red Glare Hardcover – A Marvel Premiere Classic Hardcover collecting Captain America (1998) #14-19 and material from Captain America Spotlight.
Captain America: The Trial of Captain America TPB – Continue Ed Brubaker’s acclaimed run on Captain America, this paperback collects #611-615 and #615.1. Also available in hardcover.
Dark Tower: The Fall of Gilead TPB – Collects Dark Tower: Sorcerer and Dark Tower: The Fall of Gilead #1-6. Also available in hardcover.
Fantastic Four by Waid & Wieringo Ultimate Collection Book 3 TPB – Waid mines some interesting topics but ultimate goes a bit off the rails in this collection of Fantastic Four #503-513.
Fantastic Four: 1234 Hardcover – I always sing “Senses Working Overtime” when I see the title of this HC! It collects an out-of-continuity take on the FF by comics wunderkind Grant Morrison with perennial stunner Jae Lee on pencils. Collects Fantastic Four: 1234 #1-4 and a Morrison Nick Fury story from Marvel Knights Double Shot #2.
From the Marvel Vault – An intriguing concept: printing stories that never saw light when they were originally written or illustrated. Sadly, none of these are clamored for fan favorites, though they do involve some classic creators. Includes stories from Dr. Strange, Nomad and Thunderbolts, Gambit and the Champions, and Human Torch.
Red Hulk: Planet Red Hulk TPB – Collects Hulk 31-36, 30.1, and material from 30.
Invaders Now! TPB – Collects the Invaders five-issue reunion mini-series. Also available in hardcover.
Invincible Iron Man, Vol. 7: My Monsters TPB – Collects a paltry array of Iron Man filler – #500, 500.1, Annual 1, and material from #503. Also available in hardcover.
Thor: Trials of Loki TPB – Collects a four-issue Loki limited series. Also available in hardcover.
Marvel Firsts: The 1960s TPB – Want to revel in the glory of dime-a-dozen good ideas, the majority of which turned into multi-million dollar franchises 50 years later? Beyold this collection of Marvel 1960s debuts, which is a great value for $20! Collects Rawhide Kid (1955) #17; material from Amazing Adventures (1961) #1; Fantastic Four (1961) #1; material from Tales to Astonish (1959) #27, #51 and #70; Incredible Hulk (1962) #1; material from Amazing Fantasy #15 (Spider-Man’s debut); material from Journey Into Mystery #83 (Thor); material from Strange Tales (1951) #101, #110 (Dr. Strange), & #135; Two-Gun Kid #60; material from Tales of Suspense (1959) #39 (Iron Man), #49 and #59; Sgt. Fury and His Howling Commandos #1; Avengers (1963) #1; X-Men (1963) #1; Daredevil (1964) #1; Ghost Rider (1967) #1; Marvel Super-Heroes (1967) #12 and #19-20, Captain Savage #1; and material from Silver Surfer (1968) #1.
Marvel Masterworks: The Amazing Spider-Man Vol. 6 TPB – Collects classic issues Amazing Spider-Man #51-61 and Annual 4.
Marvel Masterworks: Atlas Era Strange Tales, Vol 5 Hardcover – Collects Strange Tales #40-48.
Marvel Masterworks: The Fantastic Four Vol. 7 TPB – Collects classic stories including the Inhumans and the Negative Zone! I just picked this up in hardcover and I can’t wait to read it. Collects #61-71 and Annual 5.
Marvel Masterworks: The Incredible Hulk, Vol. 6 Hardcover – Collects The Incredible Hulk #122-134.
New Warriors Classic Vol. 3 TPB – Marvel’s hopelessly uncool, non-mutant teen team of the 90s. Collects New Warriors (1990) #11-17 and Avengers (1963) #341-342.
Punishermax: Frank Hardcover – Collects Jason Aaron’s Punishermax #12-16, and I’m sure you can guess how I feel about that. Available for pre-order as a TPB.
S.H.I.E.L.D. TPB – I found this series a bit off-putting, but if you dug Da Vinci Code or the Rimbaldi bits of Alias this book looking at Reed Richard’s father’s escapades as a SHIELD agent is definitely for you. Collects the five issue mini-series (but not the “Infinity” issue that followed). Also available in oversize hardcover.
Spider-Man: Deadly Foes of Spider-Man TPB – A spotlight on Spidey’s villains, collecting the early-90s mini-series Deadly Foes of Spider-Man #1-4 and Lethal Foes of Spider-Man #1-4.
Spider-Man: The Complete Ben Reilly Epic Book 2 TPB – Another chapter of when Spider-Man wasn’t Peter Parker! Marvel does a great job of summing these 90s mega-storylines up coherently in multi-volume sets. Collects a massive haul of Amazing Spider-Man (1962) #407-408, New Warriors (1990) #67, Sensational Spider-Man (1996) #1, Spectacular Spider-Man (1976) #230, Spider-Man (1990) #64-65, Spider-Man/Punisher: Family Plot #1-2, Web of the Scarlet Spider #3-4, and material from Spider-Man Holiday Special and Venom: Along Came a Spider #1-4. You can backtrack to Book 1, or pre-order Book 3!
Venom: Lethal Protector TPB – Not to be confused with Rick Remender’s recent Venom ongoing starring Flash Thompson, this six-issue mini-series focused on the original Venom, Eddie Brock!
Warriors Three: Dog Day Afternoon – Collects the four-issue mini-series of Asgardian supporting characters, plus a Hulk story from Tales to Astonish #101 and Incredible Hulk (1968) #102. Also available in hardcover.
Finally, here are the October books from Marvel’s Ultimate Comics line, which is a separate continuity from the main universe (and, generally, has more in common with their films).
Ultimate Comics Avengers 3 AKA Blade vs. The Avengers TPB – Collects Ultimate Avengers 3 #1-6. Also available in hardcover.
Ultimate Comics Spider-Man: Death of Spider-Man Hardcover – This story saw lots of major media hype, and in the Ultimate Universe, dead really means dead! Hype aside, it was met largely with fan praise for both story and art. Collects Ultimate Comics #156-160.
Ultimate Comics X: Origins Hardcover -Beware, X-Fans – the community at large seems to truly despite any Ultimate-X tale penned by writer Jeph Loeb. Collects Ultimate X #1-5. Also available for pre-order as a TPB.
That’s the wide world of Marvel collections for October. How many did you pick up? How many remain on your wishlist? What totally new-to-you book or character do you want to try?
Sounds like you weren’t alone on X-23, Marvel just canceled that. I’m really enjoying Hickman’s FF too.
WHOA, canceled? The first arc was weak, but it’s been really great since then.
Daken can’t be far behind. Both have been flirting with the 20k mark on sales, as has GenHope – but that benefits from being the driver of their next big event (sadly, few people are interested).