• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Crushing Krisis

Comic Books, Drag Race, & Life in New Zealand

  • DC Guides
    • DC Events
    • DC New 52
    • DC Rebirth
    • Batman Guide
    • The Sandman Universe
  • Marvel Guides
    • Marvel Events
    • Captain America Guide
    • Iron Man Guide
    • Spider-Man Guide (1963-2018)
    • Spider-Man Guide (2018-Present)
    • Thor Guide
    • X-Men Reading Order
  • Indie & Licensed Comics
    • Spawn
    • Star Wars Guide
      • Expanded Universe Comics (2015 – present)
      • Legends Comics (1977 – 2014)
    • Valiant Guides
  • Drag
    • Canada’s Drag Race
    • Drag Race Belgique
    • Drag Race Down Under
    • Drag Race Sverige (Sweden)
    • Drag Race France
    • Drag Race Philippines
    • Dragula
    • RuPaul’s Drag Race
    • RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars
  • Archive
  • Contact!
You are here: Home / consume / games / The D&D Open Gaming License / The Dangers of Playing with Other People’s Toys

The D&D Open Gaming License / The Dangers of Playing with Other People’s Toys

January 13, 2023 by krisis 2 Comments

This week everyone is talking about Dungeons & Dragons, but it’s not for a good reason.

Last week, a revision to the longstanding D&D “Open Gaming License” leaked. I’ve written about the OGL before, but in short it’s the persistent legal agreement that allows independent creators to use the core rules and concepts of D&D to create their own 3rd party material. While that ostensibly exists for people who want to sell their own 3rd-party D&D supplements, it also acts as a safety net for anyone homebrewing their own content.

Many outlets have written at length about the newly-drafted version of the OGL – i09 reporter Linda Codega broke the story at Gizmodo last week. The draft institutes a number of restrictions, including tightening the ability to distribute digital content, enforcing royalty-sharing on big earners, and instituting some potentially-invasive rights to reproduce creator content.

Understandably, both creators and players are in an uproar – after all, every D&D player is also a co-creator of their campaign’s story! Even if they never intend to publish or profit from their storytelling contributions, there’s a pervasive feeling of “this affects all of us” solidarity from the D&D community.

Another reliable leak mentioned that D&D owners Wizards of the Coast (WotC) and Hasbro would be looking at digital DNDBeyond subscription cancellations as an early metric of the community’s response to the OGL changes. A leak coming from within the DNDBeyond team makes a lot of sense. WotC and Hasbro bought DNDBeyond last April from Fandom for $146 million dollars. The DNDBeyond team don’t have a long-term allegiance to the Hasbro corporate overlords and they are watching the stellar good will they’ve amassed as a community platform being quickly eroded by this decision.

As the DNDBeyond team may have feared (but also secretly wished for), this new leak immediately lead to a cascade of hundreds of players posting proof of their subscription cancellations on DNDBeyond forums and on Twitter.

I was one of those players.

Tomorrow is my bi-weekly D&D date with my best friends from the states and I am currently the Dungeon Master of our campaign. That means today ought to be spent finalizing maps and building out potential encounters for my custom campaign that has taken a hard left turn from the official campaign in Storm King’s Thunder.

Instead, I’m spending the day wondering if it’s worth putting in the effort to tell stories in a fictional world that is just another capitalist playground.

Unrelated, but breaking just as I am drafting this post: Rick & Morty co-creator and primary voice-actor Justin Roiland has been charged with domestic violence offenses. The news has prompted many media insiders to chime in that Roiland’s abusive behavior has been a widely-known open secret in Hollywood for some time.

I don’t count myself as a Rick & Morty superfan who campaigned for McDonald’s to bring back Szechuan Sauce, but I do love the show. I enjoy how it uses the profane to say piercingly true things about the human condition. Also, I’m a massive fan of writer Jeff Loveness, and I think his Mr. Nimbus is the best adaptation of Namor that we’ll ever see.

(Coincidentally, there is a Rick & Morty D&D sourcebook.)

It feels like we’ve all been having the “Separate the art from the artist” conversation for years, especially in light of the #MeToo movement. I usually don’t have a problem with that separation. I revere David Bowie’s music even though he openly admitted to committing statutory rape. I will never fall out of love with The Beatles even though several of their songs are about John Lennon abusing his wife. We won’t even get into Michael Jackson.

In each of those cases, I can hold the art separately from the artist because I can experience the art without them. I can listen to a David Bowie song without endorsing his every action. Even if I couldn’t bear to hear John Lennon’s voice ever again, I know how to play all of his songs myself. And, I’ll always have my happy childhood memories of watching “Thriller.”

I don’t know how to do that with Dungeons & Dragons or Rick & Morty. (And that doesn’t even begin to touch the ongoing disaster of Twitter!)

For D&D, even if I cancel my subscription and don’t use a single concept, story hook, or creature from their official books, I’m still devoting dozens of hours a month to telling stories in a world that’s curated by corporate assholes. I am making new memories in their capitalist playground. I’ve always understood that I’m playing with and contributing to the spread of a product, but existence of the OGL and the massive amount of 3rd party material on the market made me feel like I was also a member of the community. I even spend a few months last year covering that community on CK!

And, for R&M, even if I don’t mind hearing Roiland’s voice for both main characters, how do I feel now about using the show as shorthand for explaining co-dependency?

I’ve had similar experiences in comics over the past decade. How did I feel about publishing new Marvel Guides when Ike Perlmutter was in charge of the brand? What about recording weekly shows about X-Men when the editors showed callous disregard in producing stories about queer characters?

These aren’t 1:1 art-to-artist relationships like songs are to songwriters. All of these brands are complex pieces of machinery cultivated by dozens of creators whose content is remixed and spread by communities of millions of fans. Also, I’m engaging with these brands as a clear-eyed adult, which is different than refusing to let an artist’s behavior taint my nostalgia or positive memories associated with their art.

These are the dangers of playing with other people’s toys, even if you aren’t literally playing with them. Every product we buy and every story we consume are produced by fallible human beings. As the saying goes, “There’s No Ethical Consumption Under Capitalism,” but this goes beyond consumption. It feels like being a fan of anything is an appointment with future disappointment.

Sometimes it makes me want to give up all of my media consumption and live completely off the entertainment grid. Yet, even if I did, I’d still be consuming food, clothes, furniture – plenty of things made by potentially-disappointing people. E and I have even stripped away many of those elements from our lives – I shop from a local farmer’s market and she makes clothes for the kid… yet, there are still people behind those products.

Is the answer living in isolation in the middle of the woods, growing your own food, making your own clothes, singing your own songs, and playing your own games?

I think there are lot of positive aspirational qualities to that life, but I also don’t think we need to deny ourselves all of the benefits and pleasures of the modern world just for fear of people disappointing us. No person can meet all of our expectations and standards perfectly. Not even ourselves.

I’m going to leave my DNDBeyond subscription cancelled for now, but I am still going to play the game with people I love tomorrow. I’ll be sure to use as many 3rd Party creatures as I can for their encounters, and I just bought a slew of digital assets from indie creators to help me tell my story. And, at the end of the session I’m going to say “I love you” to my friends, as I’ve been doing every two weeks for the past three years.

In a world where no consumption is ethical and every creator could be your next disappointment, we need to accept that we can’t beat ourselves up about every disgraced creator and we can’t participate in every boycott. I’m happy I sent Wizards of the Coast a message with my cancelled subscription, but no one benefits from us cancelling our D&D campaign or switching to another system. I don’t make the world a better place by not thinking of a funny gag on Rick & Morty or refusing to cover “Ziggy Stardust.”

The best way we can combat capitalism is to use its products to create joy whose value far outstrips what we paid.

Related posts:

  1. Krisis on Near Mint Condition, Mapping Scarlet Witch!
  2. Updated: Ms. Marvel Guide – a Kamala Khan Reading Order!
  3. zoological perspectives
  4. Crushing On: Crispy Baked Falafel (in the style of Philly’s Mama’s Vegetarian)
  5. Music Monday: “We’re Good” – Dua Lipa
  6. “you look like a god”
  7. Crushing Comics S01E080 – X-Men: Nation X and X-Necrosha

Filed Under: essays, games Tagged With: bowie, capitalism, Dungeons & Dragons, ethical consumption, friends, John Lennon, Michael Jackson, Open Gaming License, Rick & Morty, The Beatles

Previous Post: « Updated: Guide to X-Factor
Next Post: RuPaul’s Drag Race Season 15, Episode 3 – “All Queens Go To Heaven” Review & Power Ranking »

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. Breaking News: D&D continues support of Open Gaming License (OGL 1.)0, releases their core rules SRD under Creative Commons – Crushing Krisis says:
    January 27, 2023 at 4:38 pm

    […] I first wrote about these changes and the depressing effect they have on TTRPG creators and players … […]

    Reply
  2. N.K. Jemisin's The Fifth Season Roleplaying Game campaign on Backerkit (TTRPG Tuesday) – Crushing Krisis says:
    February 15, 2023 at 6:30 pm

    […] learn some RPG systems other than Dungeons and Dragons and 5th Edition! This goal was on my list even before the OGL drama of a few weeks ago, and even though that came to a happy resolution it doesn’t change the […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar


Support Crushing Krisis on Patreon
Support CK
on Patreon


Follow me on Twitter Contact me Watch me on Youtube Subscribe to the CK RSS Feed

About CK

About Crushing Krisis
About My Music
About Your Author
Blog Archive
Comics Blogs Only
Contact Krisis
Terms & Conditions

Crushing Comics

Marvel Comics

Marvel Events Guide

Spider-Man Guide

DC Comics

  • New Comics & Collected Editions: Marvel Comics – September 20, 2023
    Catch up on newly-released comic books and collected editions from Marvel Comics September 20 2023, with guides to every title & character! […]
  • New for Patrons: Guide to Monica Rambeau – Photon, Spectrum, & Captain Marvel
    It's time to shine a light on a Guide to Monica Rambeau. She's been Photon, Spectrum, & even Captain Marvel. Read EVERY issue in order. […]
  • Guide to Avengers (1963-1996)Updated: Guide to Avengers (1963-1996)
    Happy Anniversary to Marvel's Avengers! To celebrate I rebuilt my definitive guide to Avengers (1963-1996), including EVERY issue & collection. […]
  • Silver Age X-Men GuideUpdated: Silver Age X-Men Guide
    I've updated my definitive Silver Age X-Men Guide to collected editions of the earliest X-Men comics, including a new Penguin Classics & Taschen editions. […]
  • Guide to Conan the BarbarianUpdated: Guide to Conan The Barbarian
    I've overhauled my Guide to Conan the Barbarian to celebrate the release of Titan Comics' new Conan the Barbarian series written by Jim Zub. […]
  • Avengers Inc. (2023) #1 by Al Ewing & Leonard Kirk, released by Marvel Comics September 13 2023New Comics & Collected Editions: Marvel Comics – September 13, 2023
    Catch up on newly-released comic books and collected editions from Marvel Comics September 13 2023, with guides to every title & character! […]
  • Guide to Birds of PreyNew for Patrons: Guide to Birds of Prey
    Who are the Birds of Prey? Learn what cast members define one of DC's signature team with my Guide to Birds of Prey! […]
  • Fantastic Four (2022) #11 released by Marvel Comics September 6 2023New Comics & Collected Editions: Marvel Comics – September 6, 2023
    Catch up on newly-released comic books and collected editions from Marvel Comics September 6 2023, with guides to every title & character! […]
  • It’s gonna be May! Oh, wait, it’s ALREADY May…
    Hello, friends! Unfortunately, my non-CK life and […]
  • Drax GuideDrax Guide – now available to the public!
    Learn how the MCU merged several incarnations Drax into Dave Bautista's hyper-literal warrior with a vendetta agains Thanos in my Drax Guide! […]
  • Guide to GamoraGamora Guide – now available to the public!
    My Gamora Guide will help you find every Marvel comic starring Thanos's adopted daughter and the most dangerous woman in the galaxy! […]
  • Drag Race España Season 3, Episode 2 – “Drag Vision” Review & Power Rankings
    The queens of Drag Race España Season 3 make a collective stumble in this "Drag Vision" choreography challenge, earning the ire of the judges (though it's the kindest ire you'll ever see). […]
  • Star-Lord GuideStar-Lord Guide – now available to the public!
    Get ready for Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 with my Star-Lord Guide, including every comics appearance of Marvel's TWO distinct Star-Lords! […]
  • Drag Race Sverige Season 1, Episode 8 – Sweden Grand Finale, “Queen Delicious” runway, & season retrospective
    It's the Drag Race Sweden Grand Finale! Our final three queens put their spin on an original song and walk a final "Queen Delicious" runway alongside their eliminated peers. […]

Content Copyright ©2000-2023 Krisis Productions

Crushing Krisis participates in affiliate programs including (but not limited to): Amazon Services LLC Associates Program (in the US, UK, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, and Spain), eBay Partner Network, and iTunes Affiliate Program. If you make a qualifying purchase through an affiliate link I may receive a commission.