To view this content, you must be a member of Peter's Patreon
Already a qualifying Patreon member? Refresh to access this content.
The Newest Oldest Blog In New Zealand
Surprise! I’m back with a second new guide in a row for Patrons of Crushing Krisis, for yet another Asgardian leading lady… although, she started out somewhere very different (both within Marvel continuity and before she arrived at Marvel)…
One thing that DC Comics is very well known for that Marvel Comics is absolutely not known for is incorporating the characters from other publishers into their line.
Even before Crisis on Infinite Earths gave DC the infinite flexibility to subsume entire lines of characters like Wildstorm and Alan Moore’s America’s Best Comics, the DC juggernaut had absorbed entire universes of characters. They incorporated many Charlton Comics characters like Blue Beetle and Captain Atom (who also doubled as inspiration for Watchmen), and before them Fawcett Comics’ Shazam! Not to mention their self-incorporation of the many properties that branched out into the Vertigo line back to DC continuity.
Plus, DC never hesitates to engage in cross-company crossovers, as long as it’s not with Marvel. Even relatively recently we’ve seen Batman cross paths with Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, and Gotham Academy with Lumberjanes!
The only time Marvel really came close to a wholesale import of characters was through their acquisition of Malibu Comics’ Ultraverse, which they hastily shuttered.
We could speculate endlessly about why this is the case. Is it Marvel’s self-reliance that borders on stinginess? The sacrosanct nature of their 616-Universe? That DC’s characters are more iconic and stand up better to other media properties? That Marvel has less adventurous fans?
Regardless of the why, it is a very big deal when any kind of outside character makes their way into Marvel’s Universe. It’s an even bigger deal when that character was created by Neil Gaiman, was one of the original big draws during the launch of Image Comics, and has been involved in a somewhat nasty set of legal battles with her now-no-longer-officially-recognized co-creator Todd McFarlane.
I am, of course, talking about Neil Gaiman’s Angela. [Read more…] about New for Patrons: Guide to Marvel’s Angela
by krisis
It’s another Classic Collection version of Haul Around the World, shot BEFORE my big move! This was my order from mid-February 2019.
In this order I get to freak out with excitement over Marvel hitting a number of very different gaps in their color collections coverage – the end of Luke Cage’s original solo title, the post-Claremont pre-Davis gap in Excalibur, Monica Rambeau’s solo stories as Captain Marvel and the deeply weird Punisher: Revelations.
Plus… a tease of the next oversize book to hit my shelf, which might be my most-anticipated omnibus of the decade!
In this haul:
by krisis
Today’s new guide Patrons of Crushing Krisis is actually three guides (or maybe four, by the time you read this), which seems like overkill for what is essentially a single title with an obvious ten-volume paperback line. But, it’s really so much more than that…
Sandman Universe – The Definitive Reading Order and Collecting Guide
+
Books of Magic – The Definitive Reading Order and Collecting Guide
+
Lucifer – The Definitive Reading Order and Collecting Guide
I am fascinated by how Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman (and, in fact, all of the extended Sandman Universe) bridges the gap between comic books and serious literature.
That fascination has lasted for over 25 years – almost as long as Gaiman’s reinvention of the Golden Age character has existed.
Even the most-knowledgable comic fan could be forgiven for not knowing that Morpheus the King of Dreams was merely an iteration on an already-rebooted Golden Age DC hero. The original Sandman, Wesley Dodds, was a minor character who ran for seven years in the Golden Age and then popped back up twenty years later in the Earth 2 Justice Society of America in the Silver Age.
Without Gaiman and Morpheus, Dodds would probably be that one JSA member whose name you could never recall. His Silver Age iteration certainly wouldn’t jog your memory – a Kirby/Simon creation meant to be Mr. Sandman who lasted just six issues and who was later retconned in Wonder Woman to be a professor lost in the world of dreams.
There was no harm in Neil Gaiman revamping such a character to a more adult version early in the Post-Crisis years in 1989. At the time, Gaiman was still a relative unknown, coming off of the slept-on Black Orchid mini-series – a similar act of excavation and reinvention. He was so used to tepid reception to his early work that he expected Sandman to run just eight issues, which is why the first eight form such a satisfying arc despite being a mix of one-shots and continuing stories. He though that would be the whole series!
Instead, The Sandman became the springboard off of which Gaiman launched his multimedia fame in a miraculous three-year run from 1990-93 that saw him release Books of Magic at DC, the novel Good Omens (with Terry Prachett), win a World Fantasy Award in a category where Sandman wasn’t even eligible, essentially give birth to what we know as the modern American graphic novel market with the first two Sandman trade paperbacks, and top it off with the landmark Death: The High Cost of Living (the collection of which would be introduced by his friend and frequent name-checker, Tori Amos). [Read more…] about New for Patrons: The Definitive Guides to The Sandman Universe
The Sandman and The Dreaming comic books definitive issue-by-issue collecting guide and trade reading order for omnibus, hardcover, and trade paperback collections. Find every issue and appearance! Part of Crushing Krisis’s Crushing Comics. Last updated June 2020 with titles scheduled for release through December 2020.
The Sandman is both a somewhat obscure Golden Age hero revived by the Justice Society for modern audiences and one of the most widely-read characters in the history of American comics.
They are not the same character.
The Golden Age Sandman was Wesley Dodds. Dodds was an odd early take on superheroism, dressing in a sharp green three-piece suit and subduing foes with a gun that fired gas that could compel them to tell the truth or put them to sleep.
Dodds was one of many Golden Age Justice Society characters to stay constrained to Earth 2 with no Silver Age (AKA Earth 1) counterpart – although Jack Kirby and Joe Simon did briefly reinvent The Sandman in 1974 with a new character, Garrett Sanford.
In the wake of Crisis on Infinite Earths, DC could have easily reinvented either Dodds or Sanford for their new clean slate of continuity. Instead, the handed the character to a barely-known British Journalist – Neil Gaiman.
Gaiman had very little work to his name at that point, including the Mostly Harmless biography of Douglas Adams and a handful of issues of 2000 AD. However, he had successfully pitched DC on a three-issue series called Black Orchid in 1988. The series didn’t sell much, but it was well-liked by editor Karen Berger, and it was on the heels of that he pitched his re-imagination of Sandman.
In fact, Gaiman originally intended to reference the 1970s Sandman in Black Orchid, and so his initial Sandman pitch was for that character. Berger, Vertigo’s founding editor, asked him to re-pitch Sandman as a new character, and in response Gaiman devised Morpheus, one of the seven eternal Endless – immutable forces of the natural world.
They rest, as they say, is history.
Except, Sandman wasn’t an immediate pop culture force… although its first issue was popular and sales began to climb with issue #5 and never looked back. Morpheus appeared in the other proto-Vertigo titles in Swamp Thing #84 and Hellblazer #19. Later, Gaiman began to incorporate the history of the Golden and Bronze age Sandmen into his story.
The title achieved its cultural impact by degrees over the course of the next three years until The Sandman (and Neil Gaiman, along with it) reached a tipping point and broke through into the consciousness of the wider public.
In 1990, Gaiman penned The Books of Magic mini-series for Vertigo. This self-contained low fantasy story, to which Harry Potter bears a more-than-striking similarity, proved to be a massive hit that spawned its own franchise of titles (visit the guide). Shortly before that, Gaiman and Terry Prachett released the novel Good Omens. Prachett was much more famous than the neophyte Gaiman (it was his first novel), and the book was popular.
Books garnered critical attention and Omens nabbed some significant fantasy award nominations in 1991. Perhaps uncoincidentally, so did Sandman. Issue #19, a loose adaption of A Midsummer Night’s Dream, won the World Fantasy Award in 1991 for “Best Short Fiction” (after which comics were outlawed from winning in that category).
Also in 1990, DC published the Sandman trade paperback – A Doll’s House – which originally collected issues #8 (Death’s debut) through #16. It was a massive success, and DC followed it with Preludes and Nocturnes in 1991 just as Sandman won the World Fantasy Award.
The trade paperbacks were available in traditional bookstores, where it was discovered by audiences that the comic alone would never be able to reach. This, along with Watchman and several of DC’s famous Batman graphic novels, more or less created the modern American trade paperback culture.
And, finally, in the first week of 1992, Tori Amos’s Little Earthquakes was released, with its track “Tear In Your Hand” saying, “If you need me, me and Neil’ll be hanging out with The Dream King.”
Amos’s music garnered a cult following with literally-minded freaks and geeks on the fringes of grunge culture. As her audience devoured the dense mythology of her confessional and sometimes-fantastical lyrics, they stumbled upon Gaiman’s Sandman – as well as his pair of Death mini-series in the early 90s. Amos penned the introduction to the collection of The High Cost of Living.
From that point forward, The Sandman was an unstoppable juggernaut of critical praise and sales … right up until Gaiman stopped it, in March of 1996 with issue #75. It ended while still outselling most of the DC line, including comics from Batman and Superman. Gaiman had long seeded his narrative with hints of Morpheus’s end, though that didn’t necessarily mean that Sandman itself would end along with him.
The end of Sandman lead to a trio of spinoffs – a second Death mini series (The Time of Your Life) a mini-series for Destiny (A Chronicle of Deaths Foretold), and the ongoing comic The Dreaming, depicting the ongoing life of the dreamworld after Morpheus’s demise.
The Dreaming ran for five years, though it was never a hit the size of Sandman itself. Yet, its endurance allowed for the launch of several mini-series – some under the title “The Sandman Presents.” One of those mini-series starred Gaiman’s version of Lucifer as penned by Mike Carey, which spun into its own franchise with a 75-issue series in 2000 and a later 2016 revival (visit the guide).
While the character of Sandman is wholly-owned by DC, they have always shown Gaiman an extraordinary amount of deference in their use of the universe and its characters (as opposed to, say, their treatment of Alan Moore). DC continued to release titles in this extended Sandman Universe through 2014, always with Gaiman’s consent but rarely with him writing, save for Dream Hunters and Endless Nights. That changed in 2013, when Gaiman returned not only to his Sandman Universe, but to Morpheus with The Sandman Overture. Overture was a tale of Morpheus’s journey prior to The Sandman #1 with lush illustrations from JH Williams and Dave Stewart.
After a several years break from any Sandman Universe stories save for Lucifer, Dream made a surprising appearance in the 2017-18 line-wide event Metal as a sort of ephemeral shepherd to Bruce Wayne. While not directly linked to the events of Metal, Dream’s appearance there can be seen as a prelude to the 2018 relaunch of the Sandman Universe as its own self-contained line of Vertigo titles – The Dreaming, House of Whisper, and relaunches of Lucifer and Books of Magic.
Interested in learning about the core of Neil Gaiman’s Sandman, including only titles written by or directly supervised by Gaiman? Here’s the abbreviated table of contents for you:
Want to dig in to everything Sandman? It’s all covered in this guide! Click for the extended table of contents, which lists every series every associated with Sandman!
In order to fully understand this guide, you need to understand the four main Sandmen of the DC Universe, plus the The Endless – Destiny, Death, Dream, Destruction, Desire, Despair, and Delirium.
Wesley Dodds [CBDB] is a Golden Age detective and inventor who dreams of future crimes who debuted in the pages of Adventure Comics (1939). He is equipped with a gas mask and his “Silicoid Gun,” which emits his sleep gas.
Dodds lived beyond the Golden Age as one of the members of the Earth 2 Justice Society from the Silver Age and forward. Sandman Mystery Theatre, a Vertigo spinoff from Gaiman’s The Sandman, told flashback stories set prior to his Golden Age origin.
He and his full list of appearances in continuity through Crisis on Infinite Earths are detailed below.
This second Sandman [CBDB] was introduced as the actual Sandman, he of “Mister Sandman, bring me a dream.” However, that origin was retconned in one of his few further appearances in Wonder Woman (1942) #300. There, we discover he was a professor who became trapped in the dream dimension. His full appearances are detailed below.
While Gaiman would not use him directly, he did make his one-time Justice League foe Dr. Destiny into the first true villain of Sandman in issues #2-7.
Generally, when comic fans refer to “Sandman” they mean Morpheus [CBDB], Neil Gaiman’s signature creation as introduced in The Sandman (1989) #1. He very rarely has been written by anyone other than Gaiman, and always with Gaiman’s approval. He and his full appearances are detailed below.
Daniel Hall [CBDB] is the son of the Justice Society’s Fury and her husband Hector Hall (AKA Silver Scarab, Dr. Fate, and briefly as Sandman), DC characters that predate Gaiman’s Sandman. In fact, Lyta Hall can be seen to be pregnant with Daniel in Infinity, Inc. #42 in 1987!
Daniel appears in Sandman prior to succeeding Morpheus as Dream, mostly in The Kindly Ones leading to Morpheus’s death. He’s in issues #22, 40, 47, 57, 59, 61, and 65-69.
He makes limited appearances as Dream in The Sandman (1989) #69-72 & 74, The Books of Magic (1994) #13, 21, & 75, The Dreaming (1996) #29, 43, 49, 58-60, & Special #1, JLA (1997) #22-23, JSA (1999) #1, 63, & 80, Planetary (1999) #7, The Sandman Presents: The Furies (2002), Lucifer: Nirvana (2002), The Sandman: Endless Nights (2003), The Sandman: Overture (2013) #2 & 6, and Dark Nights: Metal (2017) #1-2 & 4.
He is the focal point (though not the star) of the revived The Dreaming as part of the relaunched Sandman Universe in 2018.
The Endless were introduced by Neil Gaiman in The Sandman. They are a group of seven siblings that are the embodiment of eternal, everlasting aspects of life, the universe, and everything. Morpheus is the third-eldest of the siblings.
Want a primer on each of The Endless, plus a full list of their appearances? Read more
Destiny [CBDB] is the oldest character of The Endless, having been birthed alongside the universe itself. He is blind and carries an infinite book containing the destinies of all beings in existence.
This character existed before Neil Gaiman – he was the storyteller in the framing sequences of DC’s horror anthology titles. Note that these pre-Gaiman appearances are effectively non-continuity, as we don’t learn any specific story elements about Destiny.
Weird Mystery Tales (1972) #1-14 (of 24)
Secrets of Haunted House (1975) #1-7, 9, 11-17, 19-20, 22-23, 25, 27-29, 31-35, 37-39 (of 46) & DC Special Series (1977) #12
House of Mystery (1951) #252-253, 279
Prior to Sandman, he also appears in DC Special Series (1977) #21, The Best of DC (1979) #5 , Superman (1939) #352, The New Teen Titans (1984) #8-9, History of the DC Universe (1986) #1, Elvira’s House of Mystery (1986) Special & #11
Destiny appears in The Sandman (1989) #7, 21, 28, 47, 55-56, 59, 63, 67, 70-72, & Special, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #1-2 & 5, and The Sandman: Endless Nights.
After Sandman, Destiny appeared in The Dreaming (1996) #5-6, Lucifer (2000) #51-52, as well as in his own series, Destiny: A Chronicle of Deaths Foretold (1997) #1, detailed below.
Destiny is the only Endless who has appeared independently of Dream and Death in the DC Universe. As a pre-existing DC character, he is seemingly immune to the unstated Gaiman-Embargo where all of his appearances must be explicitly approved.
He has appeared in Captain Atom (1987) #42, Books of Magic (1990) #4, The New Titans (1988) #89, Chronos (1998) #9, The Little Endless Storybook (2001), JLA: Destiny (2002) #1-3, Sandman Presents: Bast (2003) #1, Death: At Death’s Door (2003) OGN, The Sandman Presents: Thessaly: Witch for Hire (2004) #4, The Vault of Michael Allred (2006) #2 & 4, The Brave and the Bold (2007) #4 & 12, DC Retroactive: Superman – The ’80s (2011) #1, and Delirium’s Party: A Little Endless Storybook (2011).
Death [CBDB] is the second eldest of The Endless. Once the Universe was created and had its destiny set, the next thing to follow would natural be the force of death. In the modern day, she spends one day each century living life as a mortal.
A physical embodiment of Death closer to a skull-faced Grim Reaper had appeared in DC continuity prior to Crisis. However, The Endless version of Death is a pale, thin, raven-haired woman dressed in all black and wearing an ankh necklace, as inspired by Goth fashion icon Cinamon Hadley.
Death’s series and appearances are covered in a full, below.
Dream is the third eldest of The Endless. He is king and anthropomorphized form of all dreams and stories.
Dream’s series and appearances are covered in full below.
Destruction [CBDB] is the fourth-oldest Endless. He is typically depicted as a large, muscular, red-haired man, frequently wearing military garb. Early in Sandman we learn that he abandoned his domain, and we do not meet him on-panel until The Sandman #41 during “Brief Lives.”
Destruction appears in The Sandman (1989) #41-44, 46-48, 55, 72-73, & Special, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #4, and The Sandman: Endless Nights.
Destruction has never made an appearance outside of a Sandman comic or without Death.
After Sandman, Destruction appears in The Little Endless Storybook (2001) OGN, 9-11 (2002) Vol. 2 OGN, The Vault of Michael Allred (2006) #2, and Delirium’s Party: A Little Endless Storybook (2011) OGN.
Desire [CBDB] is Despair’s twin and is depicted as various genders or androgynously. We first meet them on-panel in The Sandman (1989) #10, and learn that they have a long-standing enmity with Dream.
Desire appears in The Sandman (1989) #10, 16, 21, 31, 41-42, 45, 47, 49, 55-56, 59, 65, 70-72, & Special, The Sandman: A Gallery Of Dreams (1994) #1, Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #1, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #3 & 6, and The Sandman: Endless Nights.
Desire has never made an appearance outside of a Sandman comic or without Death save for a cameo in Warren Ellis’s Transmetropolitan and in Hellblazer (2015) #8.
After Sandman, Desire appears in The Little Endless Storybook (2001) OGN SC, Death: At Death’s Door (2003) OGN SC, The Vault of Michael Allred (2006) #2 & 4, Delirium’s Party: A Little Endless Storybook (2011) OGN
There are two iterations of Despire, Desire’s twin. The incarnation we know [CBDB] is a short, heavy-set women who always appears in the nude. Her previous incarnation [CBDB] was murdered and appears only in Endless Nights.
Despair appears in The Sandman (1989) #10, 21, 31, 41, 47, 49, 56, 59, 70-72 & Special, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #6, and The Sandman: Endless Nights.
Despair has never made an appearance outside of a Sandman comic or without Death.
After Sandman, Despair appears in The Little Endless Storybook (2001) OGN SC, Death: At Death’s Door (2003) OGN, The Vault of Michael Allred (2006) #2 & 4, Delirium’s Party: and A Little Endless Storybook (2011) OGN
Delirium [CBDB] is the youngest of The Endless. She appears in the form of a young girl, often in punk rock clothing or hair styles.
Delirium appears in The Sandman (1989) #21, 31, 41-49, 55-56, 59, 63-64, 66, 68-72 & Special, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #3 & 6, and The Sandman: Endless Nights.
She was previously known as Delight [CBDB] as seen only in “Brief Lives” in The Sandman (1989) #42 & 47, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #3, and The Sandman: Endless Nights. She changed her name and nature due to some unknown event.
Delirium has never made an appearance outside of a Sandman comic or without Death save for in Lucifer (2000) #52.
After Sandman, Delirium appears in The Little Endless Storybook (2001) OGN, Death: At Death’s Door (2003) OGN, Lucifer (2000) #52, The Vault of Michael Allred (2006) #2 & 4, Delirium’s Party: A Little Endless Storybook (2011) OGN
While Wesley Dodds is no immortal deity, he does have Morpheus’s mask. He starred in his own featured stories in Adventure Comics (1939) until 1946, at which point he disappeared from DC continuity for 20 years. He was also a founding member of the Justice Society of America in All-Star Comics (1940).
This Vertigo series launched by Matt Wagner in 1993 is generally set prior to Wesley Dodds joining the Justice Society of America, which was formed in All-Star Comics (1940) #3.
in a 2016 reprint line…
#1-12: Book 1 (2016 paperback)
#13-24 & Annual 1: Book 2 (2017 paperback)
#25-70: Not collected in this format
as originally collected…
#1-4: Vol. 1: The Tarantula (1995 paperback, ISBN 9781563891953)
A retelling of Wesley Dodd’s first appearance in Adventure Comics (1938) #40.
#5-12: Vol. 2: The Face and The Brute (2004 paperback)
#13-16: Vol. 3: The Vamp
#17-20: Vol. 4: The Scorpion (2006 paperback)
Annual 1: Not collected
#21-28: Vol. 5: Dr. Death and The Night of the Butcher
#29-36: Vol. 6: The Hourman and The Python
Sandman Midnight Theatre OGN (1995)
Also collected in Absolute Sandman, Vol. 5 and The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3
#37-44: Vol. 7: The Mist and The Phantom of the Fair
#45-52: Vol. 8: The Blackhawk and The Return of the Scarlet Ghost
#53-56: Not collected; “The Crone”
#57-60: Not collected; “The Cannon”
#61-64: Not collected; “The City”
#65-68: Not collected; “The Goblin”
#69-70: Not collected; “The Hero”
Dream States: The Collected Dreaming, Sandman Presents and Overture Covers 1997-2014
Adventure Comics (1939) was an anthology series with multiple stories per issue. At first, Sandman was the only character who lived on to the modern age to appear, although that changed with the introduction of The Hourman in issue #48. Hourman’s stories from #48-52 are collected in JSA Archive volumes. Golden Age Starman first appears in issue #61 and quickly becomes the leading feature in the title until Simon & Kirby take over Sandman with #72.. His stories from #61-102 are collected in Golden Age Starman Archives.
In a weird quirk of Golden Age publishing, Sandman first appeared in The New York World’s Fair Comics (1939) #1 by a matter of weeks, though it is clear that the story in Adventure Comics (1939) #40 was meant to be his debut.
#40-59: The Golden Age Sandman Archives, Vol. 1 (2005 hardcover)
Also collects The New York World’s Fair Comics (1939) #1-2. The World’s Fair issues are also presented in full in The DC Comics Rarities Archives, Volume 1
#60-102: Sandman stories are not collected. A story from #67 is in The Greatest Golden Age Stories Ever Told (1990), but I believe it’s the Starman or Hourman story.
#72-97 & 100-102: The Sandman by Joe Simon & Jack Kirby (2009 hardcover)
Collects Adventure Comics (1938) #72-97 & 100-102, The Sandman (1974) #1, and World’s Finest Comics (1941) #6-7
#82: A DC Universe Christmas (2000 paperback)
Collects the Sandman story, “Santa Fronts for the Mob.”
#98-99: Not collected
In this period, Dodds also appears in Boy Commandos (1942) #1 (in Winter 1942) and a Boy Commandos story in Detective Comics (1937) #76 (in June 1943), both by Kirby. Dodds later appears in Adventure Comics (1939) #461-462, 466, & 498 in the title’s late-70s revival.
Wesley Dodds is one of the already-established heroes to launch All-Star Comics [CBDB] in the summer of 1940 along with Hawkman, Ultra-Man, Flash, Spectre, and Hourman.
Starting from issue #3 this was the home title of the Justice Society of America. Unlike modern team books, frequently the model of this anthology series was to present a brief team meeting or adventure followed by the simultaneous solo adventures of the various team members.
#1-2: All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 0 (2006, ISBN 978-1401207915)
Collects both issues in full. A later-published Volume 1 began collecting from issue #3 because it was the first appearance of the Justice Society of America, of which Wesley Dodds is a founding member.
#1-2: All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 0 (2006, ISBN 978-1401207915)
#2 Justice Society of America: A Celebration of 75 Years (2015) – HC
#3-6: All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 1 (1997, ISBN 978-1563890192)
#4 Justice Society of America: A Celebration of 75 Years (2015) – HC
#7-10: All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 2 (1997, ISBN 978-0930289126)
Issue #8 is the first appearance of Wonder Woman, and has been widely-collected. See Wonder Woman for more information.
#11-14: All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 3 (1997, ISBN 978-1563893704)
#15-18:All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 4 (1998, ISBN 978-1563894336)
#19-23: All Star Comics – Archives, Vol. 5 (1999, ISBN 978-1563894978)
Dodds later appears in issue #74 during the title’s revival in 1978.
Wesley Dodds briefly receives a feature in this anthology title co-headlined by stories from Batman and Superman.
#3-5: Not collected. Note that Batman and Superman stories from these issues are collected separately, but not the entire issues.
#6-7: The Sandman by Joe Simon & Jack Kirby (2009 hardcover)
Collects Adventure Comics (1938) #72-97 & 100-102, The Sandman (1974) #1, and World’s Finest Comics (1941) #6-7
Much later, issue #226 reprints Adventure Comics (1939) #87 and #265 features Dodds as part of the Justice Society.
Wesley Dodds returns to continuity in Justice League of America (1960) #46. This is “Crisis Between Earth-One and Earth-Two,” the fourth Silver Age story that revived the Golden Age Justice Society characters to fight alongside the Silver Age Justice League. From there on , Dodds would consistently appear in Justice Society revivals.
Click to expand a list of post-Golden Age appearances.Adventure Comics #461-462, 466, 498: Appearing with the JSA.
Justice League of America #46-47, 64-65, 82, 100-102, 107-108, 113, 146, 193: See Justice League or DC Elseworlds and Alternate Earths. Appearing with the JSA.
Wonder Woman (1942) #231-232 & 238: See Wonder Woman. These stories are headlined by the Earth 2 AKA Golden Age Wonder Woman, rather than her Silver Age version.
DC Special (1975) #29: “The Untold Origin of the Justice Society” collected in Justice Society Vol. 1 and in black and white in Showcase Presents: All-Star Comics, Vol. 1
Adventure Comics (1939) #461-462, 466, & 498: Appearing with the JSA.
DC Comics Presents (1978) #25, 42, 47: Appearing with the JSA
World’s Finest Comics (1941) #265: Appearing with the JSA
All-Star Squadron (1981) #1-5, 7, 17-22, 25, 27-28, 30-32, 38, 41, 43, 50-51, 53-56, 59-60, 64-67, & Annuals 2-3: See DC Elseworlds and Alternate Earths
America vs. the Justice Society (1985) #1-4: See DC Elseworlds and Alternate Earths
Infinity Inc. (1984) #21, 25, 27, 30, 34, & Annual 2: See DC Elseworlds and Alternate Earths
Last Days of the Justice Society Special (1986) Special: See DC Elseworlds and Alternate Earths
Young All-Stars (1987) #1-4, 9, 14-15, 20, 27, & Annual 1: See DC Elseworlds and Alternate Earths. A Post-Crisis continuation of the All-Star Squadron
Further Post-Crisis appearances with the JSA or All-Star Squadron are not tracked by this guide.
This Vertigo series told a pair of parallel stories – one of a new, modern-day Sandman superhero, and one depicting the final adventure of the JSA version of Dodds prior to his death in JSA Secret Files [and Origins] (1999) #1.
#1-5: Sandman Mystery Theatre: Sleep of Reason (2007 paperback)
Joe Simon and Jack Kirby revived The Sandman as an all-new character in the Bronze Age in a short-lived series.
#1-6: The Jack Kirby Omnibus, Vol. 2 (2011 hardcover)
Issue #1 also collected in The Sandman by Joe Simon & Jack Kirby
Cancelled Comic Cavalcade (1978) #2: The Kamandi Challenge Special (2017)
Cancelled Comic Cavalcade printed the story intended for issue #7; another version of this appears in The Best of DC (1979) #22.
Garrett Sanford makes further appearances in Wonder Woman (1942) #295 & 300, Justice League of America (1960) Annual 1, Last Days of the Justice Society Special (1986) Special, Swamp Thing (1985) #62, Infinity, Inc. (1984) #50, The Sandman Presents: The Thessaliad (2002) #2, Ambush Bug: Year None (2008) #1, and Bug! The Adventures of Forager (2017) #1-4
Despite being one of DC’s most famous modern creations, Sandman remains relatively unexposed to the rest of the DC universe. The Sandman universe is continued in two other titles first The Dreaming and, later, Lucifer.
A word on Sandman collections and “recoloring.” The earliest issues of Sandman have been significantly digitally recolored in a manner more in keeping with modern colors – less explosive and impressionistic blues, greens, and purples, and more realistic colors and muddy shadows. The bad news is, all 2010 and later collected editions reflect these colors. The good news is, it’s only on the earliest issues, and the style of the colors still matches the original period – just not the choices.
The Absolute Editions are deluxe, super-oversized hardcovers in slipcases. They are the most complete version of Sandman as of this writing. There are no significant Morpheus-as-Sandman stories that are not collected here but are collected elsewhere.
The Absolute Sandman, Volume One
Collects #1-20 and original script for #19.
The Absolute Sandman, Volume Two
Collects #21-39, The Sandman: A Gallery Of Dreams (1994) #1, and material from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #1 – plus original script for #23.
The Absolute Sandman, Volume Three
Collects #40-56 & Special, The Endless Gallery (1995) #1, material from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #3, and material from Vertigo Preview (1992) #1 (and expanded pages from that story from the original collection of Fables and Reflections)
The Absolute Sandman, Volume Four
Collects #57-75, additional pages of #72 from The Dreaming (1996) #8, and material from Vertigo Jam (1993) #1
The various supporting Sandman short story releases from 1995 to 2009 are collected in a fifth Absolute volume.
The Absolute Sandman, Volume Five
Collects (in order of release) Sandman Midnight Theatre (1995) OGN, “The Last Sandman Story” prose story from Dust Covers: The Collected Sandman Covers, 1989-1997, The Sandman: The Dream Hunters OGN (1999), The Sandman: Endless Nights OGN (2003), and The Sandman: The Dream Hunters (2009) #1-4
The series is accompanied by two supporting Absolute volumes, which are listed here but also repeated below along with their respective series.
The Absolute Death (2020 reprint)
Collects The Sandman (1989) #8 & 20, Death: The High Cost of Living (1993) #1-3, A Death Gallery (1994) #1, Death Talks About Life (1994) #1, Death: The Time of Your Life (1996) #1-3 (and material from the HC collection), The Sandman: Endless Nights OGN (2003), and material from “A Winter’s Tale” from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #2 and “The Wheel” from 9-11 (2002) OGN Vol. 2
The Absolute Sandman: Overture
Collects The Sandman: Overture (2013) #1-6 in both color and black and white
The Sandman Omnibuses are oversize hardcover tomes with handsome leatherette spins and durable binding. They are smaller in size than Absolute editions. If you buy Omnibuses Vol. 1-2, you will have the equivalent of Absolutes Vol. 1-4 minus The Endless Gallery (1995) #1 and potentially some script and bonus material. Omnibus Vol. 3 is a mixture of the material in Absolute Vol. 5, Absolute Death, and Absolute Sandman: Overture (to my knowledge, only omitting “The Last Sandman Story” and the B&W version of Overture).
The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 1
Collects #1-37 & Special
The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 2
Collects #38-75, additional pages of #72 from The Dreaming (1996) #8, “The Last Sandman Story” from Dust Covers: The Collected Sandman Covers, 1989-1997, and material from material from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #1 & 3, Vertigo Jam (1993) #1, and material Vertigo Preview (1992) #1 (including expanded pages from that story from the original collection of Fables and Reflections)
The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3
Note that the solicited contents of this volume are incomplete! Collects (in order of release) Death: The High Cost of Living (1993) #1-3, A Death Gallery (1994) #1, Death Talks About Life (1994) #1, The Sandman: A Gallery Of Dreams (1994) #1, Sandman Midnight Theatre (1995) OGN, The Endless Gallery (1995) #1, Death: The Time of Your Life (1996) #1-3, The Sandman: The Dream Hunters OGN (1999), The Sandman: Endless Nights OGN (2003), The Sandman: The Dream Hunters (2009) #1-4, The Sandman: Overture (2013) #1-6, and material from “A Winter’s Tale” from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #2 and “The Wheel” from 9-11 (2002) OGN Vol. 2.
These annotated editions are not well-reviewed by fans. They include grayscale artwork that is pushed all the way to the margins with small, white-on-black margins on the outside page edges. From what I have heard from other collectors, the annotations are not especially enlightening.
The Annotated Sandman, Vol. 1
Annotates issues #1-20
The Annotated Sandman, Vol. 2
Annotates issues #21-39
The Annotated Sandman, Vol. 3
Annotates issues #40-56 & Special and the short story from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge #3.
The Annotated Sandman, Vol. 4
Annotates issues #57-75
The Sandman Companion (1999 hardcover / 2000 paperback)
An issue-by-issue annotation of Sandman, though this does not collect any of the actual issues of the title.
Hanging Out With the Dream King: Interviews with Neil Gaiman and His Collaborators (2005 paperback)
Sandman Papers An Exploration of the Sandman Mythology (2006 paperback)
A collection of 12 essays discussing Sandman stories and themes.
The 10 volumes of Sandman have collecting been in print for nearly 30 years, which means there are many printings and editions of them! Generally, there is no reason you would want anything but the newest version unless you are seeking the original coloring of the first 18 issues – which you can see in versions prior to the 2010 “New Editions” of the first three volumes. While all of Sandman has been “remastered” at this point, it’s issues #1-18 where the coloring is distinctly different.
The Sandman Slipcase Set (2012 paperback)
A 2012 box set of the recolored paperbacks, below. Despite some listings as “hardcover,” this 2012 edition definitely collects paperbacks!
The Sandman 30th Anniversary Box Set (2020 paperback)
This revised box set contains the initial 10 volumes plus the other volumes that received 30th Anniversary editions – Endless Nights, both versions of Dream Hunters, and Overture.
Vol. 1: Preludes and Nocturnes
(original 1991 paperback, ISBN 978-0446393638 / 1993 Vertigo paperback, ISBN 978-1563890116 / 1995 hardcover, ISBN 978-0329408725 / 1998 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563892271 / 2010 “New Edition” paperback, ISBN 978-1401225759 / 2018 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #1-8
Vol. 2: The Doll’s House
(1990 paperback / 1991 paperback, ISBN 978-0930289591 / 1995 hardcover / 1999 hardcover / 2010 “New Edition” paperback / 2018 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #9-16. Collections from prior to 1999 may also include issue #8
Vol. 3: Dream Country
(1991 Vertigo paperback, ISBN 978-1563890161 / 1995 hardcover / 1999 hardcover / 2010 “New Edition” paperback / 2018 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #17-20
Vol. 4: Season of Mists
(original 1992 paperback, ISBN 978-1852864477 / 1992 hardcover / 1999 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563890352 / 2011 “New Edition” paperback / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #21-28
Vol. 5: A Game of You
(original 1993 paperback / 1993 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563890932 / 1999 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563890932 / 2011 “New Edition” paperback, ISBN 978-1401230432/ 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #32-37 (yes, it skipped #29-31)
Vol. 6: Fables and Reflections
(original 1994 paperback / 1993 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563891069 / 1999 hardcover reprint / 2011 “New Edition” paperback, ISBN 978-1401231231 / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #29-31, 38-40, 50, Special, and material from Vertigo Preview (1992) #1 (and expanded pages from that story from the original collection of Fables and Reflections)
Vol. 7: Brief Lives
(original 1994 paperback / 1994 hardcover / 1999 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563891373 / 2011 “New Edition” paperback, ISBN 978-1401232634 / 2018 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #41-49
Vol. 8: Worlds’ End
(original 1995 paperback / 1995 hardcover / 1999 “Book VIII” hardcover, ISBN 978-1563891700 / 2010 “New Edition” paperback / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #51-56
Vol. 9: The Kindly Ones
(original 1996 paperback, ISBN 978-1563892059 / 1996 hardcover, ISBN 978-1563892042 / 1999 “Book IX” hardcover / 2012 “New Edition” paperback, ISBN 978-1401235451 / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #57-69 and material from Vertigo Jam (1993) #1
Vol. 10: The Wake
(original 1997 paperback, ISBN 978-1563892790 / 1997 hardcover / 1999 “Book X” hardcover, ISBN 978-1563892875 / 2012 “New Edition” paperback, IBSN 978-1401237547 / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Collects #70-75 and additional pages of #72 from The Dreaming (1996) #8
Sandman Midnight Theatre OGN (1995)
Though this happens long the past (during Morpheus’s imprisonment), in terms of story placement it should be read between #71-72
The Sandman Gallery Edition (2015)
Collects reproductions of the original full-size pencil and ink illustrations from The Sandman (1989) #1, The Sandman: The Dream Hunters (2009) #1-4, Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #2
Dustcovers: The Collected Sandman Covers 1989-1997 (1997 hardcover / 1998 paperback)
Includes “The Last Sandman Story” prose story
Prior to his series in Sandman Mystery Theatre (1993) #1, 12, 22, 25-26 67-68, & 70
Around the start of Sandman in Swamp Thing (1985) #84 and Hellblazer (1988) #19
During his series in Amazing Heroes Swimsuit Special (1990) #1-3, Books of Magic (1990) #3, Swamp Thing (1985) #118, Ambush Bug Nothing Special (1992) #1, Vertigo Rave (1994) #1, and Vertigo Visions: Prez (1995) #1
After the end of Sandman, Dream appears (in flashback or memory) in The Dreaming (1996) #8, 12, 25, 35, 39, The Girl Who Would Be Death (1998) #1, Neil Gaiman’s Midnight Days (1999), The Sandman Presents: Love Street (1999) #3, The Little Endless Storybook (2001) OGN SC, Mystic (2000) #15, Green Arrow (2001) #9, The Sandman Presents: The Furies (2002) OGN HC, Lucifer (2000) #21, 31, & 75, Death: At Death’s Door (2003) OGN, The Vault of Michael Allred (2006) #1-4, Delirium’s Party: A Little Endless Storybook (2011) OGN, Dark Night: A True Batman Story (2016) OGN, and Doctor Fate (2015) #18
A anthology of short stories edited by Neil Gaiman
The Sandman: Book of Dreams (1996 hardcover / 1997 paperback / 2002 paperback)
A prose novella written by Gaiman to resemble Japanese folklore and illustrated by Final Fantasy concept illustrator Yoshitaka Amano. This was released as a “eleventh volume” of Sandman, but in story order it occurs (if it “occurs” as such) prior to Overture.
The Sandman: The Dream Hunters OGN (1999 hardcover / 2000 paperback / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Also collected in The Absolute Sandman, Volume Five and The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3
Later, the same story was adapted to comic form by P. Craig Russell.
(2009) #1-4: The Sandman: The Dream Hunters (2009 hardcover / 2010 paperback / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Also collected in The Absolute Sandman, Volume Five and The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3
An original graphic novel anthology of seven stories of the seven Endless, all written by Neil Gaiman. While some of the tales are set far in the past, Destruction and Delirium’s are both set after the conclusion of Sandman.
The Sandman Endless Nights OGN (2003 hardcover / 2004 paperback / 2013 paperback / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Also collected in The Absolute Sandman, Volume Five and The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3
This 2013 25th anniversary series acts as a prelude to Sandman, explaining how Morpheus wound up in captivity for nearly a century at the start of the series. While it is set before the series, I wouldn’t suggest reading it first if you have never read Sandman before! However, it makes for a good prologue on re-read, after you already know the character.
The Absolute Sandman: Overture
Collects The Sandman: Overture (2013) #1-6 in both color and black and white.
#1-6: The Sandman: Overture (2015 deluxe oversize hardcover / 2016 paperback / 2019 30th Anniversary paperback)
Also collected in The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3
Dream States: The Collected Dreaming, Sandman Presents and Overture Covers 1997-2014
Death’s first mini-series began the same month as Sandman (1989) #47 and told the story of the one day of the century where she walked among mortals.
“Death Talks about Life” was a brief safe(r) sex awareness story originally ran in full in each of Hellblazer (1988) #62, The Sandman (1989) #46, and Shade, the Changing Man (1990) #32. It is routinely collected along with her 1993 mini-series.
The Absolute Death (2020 reprint)
Collects The Sandman (1989) #8 & 20, Death: The High Cost of Living (1993) #1-3, A Death Gallery (1994) #1, Death Talks About Life (1994) #1, Death: The Time of Your Life (1996) #1-3 (and material from the HC collection), The Sandman: Endless Nights (2003) OGN, and material from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #2 and 9-11 (2002) OGN Vol. 2
Death: The Deluxe Edition (2012) (2012 oversize hardcover / 2014 paperback)
Death: The High Cost of Living (1993 hardcover / 1994 paperback)
Also, issue The High Cost of Living #1 is collected in Vertigo: First Taste (2005). Also collected in The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3.
The Absolute Death (2020 reprint)
Collects The Sandman (1989) #8 & 20, Death: The High Cost of Living (1993) #1-3, A Death Gallery (1994) #1, Death Talks About Life (1994) #1, Death: The Time of Your Life (1996) #1-3 (and material from the HC collection), The Sandman: Endless Nights (2003) OGN, and material from Vertigo: Winter’s Edge (1998) #2 and 9-11 (2002) OGN Vol. 2
Death: The Deluxe Edition (2012) (2012 oversize hardcover / 2014 paperback)
Death: The Time of Your Life (1996 hardcover / 1997 paperback)
Also collected in The Sandman Omnibus, Vol. 3.
This series does not actually star Death, but focuses on a girl who finds herself in possession of Death’s lost Ankh necklace.
#1-4: Not collected
A graphic novel by Jill Thompson set during the events of “Season of Mists.”
Death: At Death’s Door OGN (2003)
This has not since been recollected
The extended world of Sandman has a large crossover with the supporting cast of Hellblazer, and some of these series could be thought of as Hellblazer supporting series as well. See Guide to Hellblazer for more details.
By order of release:
While Neil Gaiman’s original series for DC is not explicitly tied to Sandman, it is the prototype of him reinventing a Bronze Age hero for an adult audience. Also, the subsequent volume connects to “The Children’s Crusade,” which is a part of Books of Magic, which is part of the extended Sandman Universe!
#1-3: Black Orchid (1993 paperback / deluxe oversize hardcover 2012 / 2013 deluxe paperback)
#1-4: Not collected
#5: Not collected; “The Mind Fields,” crossover to Swamp Thing (1985) #139
#6-16: Not collected
#17-22: Not collected; “A Twisted Season”
Annual 1: Not collected; part of “Children’s Crusade”
A story of The Furies from James Robinson.
#1-4: Witchcraft (1994 paperback)
#1-3: Destiny: A Chronicle of Deaths Foretold
Moreso than any other book in the extended Sandman Universe, this series is the direct continuation of Gaiman’s The Sandman. It extends the story of his kingdom of dreams and its oddball cast, like Cain, Abel, Muriel, Brian, Merv, Eve, and more. Note that issue #8 contains additional story pages for Sandman (1989) #72, and is collected thoroughly along with that story, above.
#1-8: Vol. 1: Beyond the Shores of Night
#9-12: Not collected; “Weird Romance”
#13-14: Not collected; “Coyote’s Kiss”
#15-19 & 22-25: Vol 2: Through the Gates of Horn and Ivory (1999 paperback)
#20-21: Not collected; “Tears for a Dark Rose”
#26, Special, & 27-34: Not collected; “Many Mansions.” The Special was released between #25-26, but fits between #26-27.
#35: Not collected
#36-38: Not collected; “The Gyres”
#39: Not collected
#40-43: Not collected; “Fox and Hounds”
#44-49: Not collected; “Trinket”
#50-51: Not collected
#52-54: Not collected; “Exiles”
#55: Collected in both Bad Doings and Big Ideas: A Bill Willingham Deluxe Edition (2011 hardcover) and The Sandman Presents: Taller Tales (2003 paperback)
#56: Not collected; “The Further Adventures of…”
#57-60: Not collected; “Rise”
Dream States: The Collected Dreaming, Sandman Presents and Overture Covers 1997-2014
A story of The Furies from James Robinson and Michael Zulli.
#1-3: Not collected
#1-3: Not collected
Merv Pumpkinhead, Agent of D.R.E.A.M. OGN (2000)
Recollected in both Bad Doings and Big Ideas: A Bill Willingham Deluxe Edition (2011 hardcover) and The Sandman Presents: Taller Tales (2003 paperback)
Written by Lucifer‘s Mike Carey.
#1-4: Vertigo Resurrected: The Sandman Presents – Petrefax (2011)
Written by Bill Willingham of Fables.
#1: in both Bad Doings and Big Ideas: A Bill Willingham Deluxe Edition (2011 hardcover) and The Sandman Presents: Taller Tales (2003 paperback)
Written by Ed Brubaker.
#1-4: The Sandman Presents: Dead Boy Detectives (2008 paperback)
A children’s book of The Endless from Jill Thompson.
The Little Endless Storybook (2001 paperback / 2004 hardcover)
A second “Little Endless Storybook” from Jill Thompson.
Delirium’s Party: A Little Endless Storybook (2011 hardcover)
Writer Darko Macan expands the story of The Corinthian from “The Kindly Ones,” as set in the 1920s.
#1-3: Not collected
Written by Lucifer’s Mike Carey.
The Sandman Presents: The Furies OGN (2002 hardcover / 2003 paperback)
Written by Bill Willingham of Fables.
#1-4: in both Bad Doings and Big Ideas: A Bill Willingham Deluxe Edition (2011 hardcover) and The Sandman Presents: Taller Tales (2003 paperback)
#1-3: Not collected
Lucifer appears in three issues of this series written by Jonathan Vankin.
#1-10: Not collected
Written by Bill Willingham of Fables.
#1-4: The Sandman Presents: Thessaly, Witch for Hire
An OGN by Jill Thompson.
Co-written and pencilled by Mark Buckingham.
#1-6: Vol. 1: School Boy Terrors
Also collects a three-part Dead Boy Detectives story from anthology titles Ghosts (2012) #1, Time Warp (2013) #1, and The Witching Hour (2013) #1.
#7-12: Vol. 2: Ghost Snow
After over a decade of absence, Daniel Hall turned up (with Neil Gaiman’s blessing) in Dark Nights: Metal (2017) #1-2 & 4 as a guiding spirit for Batman on his quest.
Then, in August of 2018, a one-shot – The Sandman Universe – launched a quartet of additional series – The Dreaming, House of Whispers, a resurrection of Books of Magic, and a new volume of Lucifer.
#1-6: Vol. 1: Pathways and Emanations (2019 paperback)
Also collects Sandman Universe #1
#7-12: Vol. 2: Empty Shells (2020 paperback, ISBN 978-1401295639)
#13-20: Vol. 3: One Magical Movement (2020 paperback, ISBN 978-1779502834)
Didn’t find what you were looking for?
Check Amazon for DC’s newest Sandman and The Dreaming comics